The Trouble with Sarah
- Jan 20, 2026
- 1:22:24
- Full Episode
Synchronizing the audio with the ad breaks and transcriptThis takes a brief moment, please wait.
The suspicious death of Sarah Hartsfield’s fifth husband leads investigators to a past filled with failed romances and wild allegations. Keith Morrison reports.
Lester Holt and Keith Morrison go behind the scenes of the making of this episode in ‘Talking Dateline’
Listen on Apple: https://apple.co/49RI4kc
Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/6LR8fUEw1bU89R2ngcQ4vk
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Brief Summary
Sarah Hartsfield, accused of murdering her husband Joe, faces a complex investigation revealing her manipulative past and violent behavior.
Key points
- A Ticking Time Bomb. Detective Rocks uncovers a web of manipulation and deceit surrounding Sarah Hartsfield.
- The Trouble with Sarah. A team of women fights to uncover the truth behind Sarah Hartsfield's dark past.
- The Illusion of Perfection. Sarah Hartsfield's life appears perfect, but her children's accounts reveal a darker reality.
- A Family Torn Apart. Cody's inheritance leads to a fiery confrontation with Sarah, revealing deep family tensions.
- A Shocking Discovery. Chris catches Sarah cheating, leading to a swift end to their marriage.
- A Dangerous Secret. Ashley learns of a chilling plot involving her mother and a hit on her father's new wife.
Episode highlights
- A Ticking Time BombDetective Rocks uncovers a web of manipulation and deceit surrounding Sarah Hartsfield.“I felt like she was a ticking time bomb.”0:48Jan 20, 2026
- The Trouble with SarahA team of women fights to uncover the truth behind Sarah Hartsfield's dark past.“Is this widow a killer?”1:07Jan 20, 2026
- The Illusion of PerfectionSarah Hartsfield's life appears perfect, but her children's accounts reveal a darker reality.“To the neighbors, Sarah projected perfection.”22:41Jan 20, 2026
- A Family Torn ApartCody's inheritance leads to a fiery confrontation with Sarah, revealing deep family tensions.“It just roared right through the house, the smoke just bellowing.”29:03Jan 20, 2026
- A Shocking DiscoveryChris catches Sarah cheating, leading to a swift end to their marriage.“What could she say?”36:46Jan 20, 2026
- A Dangerous SecretAshley learns of a chilling plot involving her mother and a hit on her father's new wife.“George had told her that my mom wouldn't let George back in the house until he killed Heather.”49:07Jan 20, 2026
- Sarah's ArrestSarah Hartsfield was arrested for murder just days after her husband's death.“They arrested me. And I was like, for what? And she said, murder.”1:01:31Jan 20, 2026
- The Jury's VerdictThe jury deliberated for about an hour before reaching a verdict in Sarah's case.“Luckily, for those anticipating the verdict in the case of Sarah Hartsfield, the wait was not very long at all.”1:16:07Jan 20, 2026
Episode quotes
Tension
85/ 100High tension
