The Girl in the Blue Mustang - Ep. 3: Like a Voice from the Grave
- Feb 16, 2026
- 37:06
- Full Episode
Synchronizing the audio with the ad breaks and transcriptThis takes a brief moment, please wait.
A retired sheriff’s deputy sees Michelle O’Keefe’s smiling face on a billboard and asks to join the investigation. This episode was originally published on March 21, 2023.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Brief Summary
The episode details Michelle O'Keefe's murder, the investigation, and the trials of Raymond Jennings, highlighting family struggles for justice.
Key points
- Jason's Grief and Baseball. After losing his sister, Jason O'Keefe found solace in baseball and faith.
- The Eyewitness Account. An eyewitness shares chilling details about Michelle's last moments.
- The PowerPoint Presentation. Michelle's family creates a compelling PowerPoint to present evidence against Jennings.
- The Arrest of Raymond Jennings. Raymond Jennings is arrested, raising questions about his involvement in Michelle's murder.
- The Mistrial. The jury could not reach a unanimous decision, resulting in a mistrial.
- Second Trial Begins. Trial 2 began on January 8, 2009, with Jennings maintaining his innocence.
Episode highlights
- Jason's Grief and BaseballAfter losing his sister, Jason O'Keefe found solace in baseball and faith.“Really the only thing that helped...was baseball.”0:37Feb 16, 2026
- The Eyewitness AccountAn eyewitness shares chilling details about Michelle's last moments.“When I first seen her, the gunshot in her chest...”2:43Feb 16, 2026
- The PowerPoint PresentationMichelle's family creates a compelling PowerPoint to present evidence against Jennings.“So we put together a PowerPoint.”10:28Feb 16, 2026
- The Arrest of Raymond JenningsRaymond Jennings is arrested, raising questions about his involvement in Michelle's murder.“I've been in Iraq. Is this about Michelle O'Keefe?”15:05Feb 16, 2026
- The MistrialThe jury could not reach a unanimous decision, resulting in a mistrial.“They could not get beyond 9-3 for conviction.”24:26Feb 16, 2026
- Second Trial BeginsTrial 2 began on January 8, 2009, with Jennings maintaining his innocence.26:23Feb 16, 2026
- Another Hung JuryAfter five weeks, the jury was hung again, this time 11 to 1 for guilt.“It's horrible. You know, 11 to 1.”32:31Feb 16, 2026
- The Impact of the TrialsMichelle's brother Jason reflects on the emotional toll of the trials and his future aspirations.“I plan on going on and being a prosecutor after this is all said and done.”34:42Feb 16, 2026
Episode quotes
Tension
75/ 100High tension
