Return to the Lake
- Feb 18, 2025
- 1:23:19
- Full Episode
Exclusive new details in the case of Susan Smith, who murdered her two young boys in 1994. Craig Melvin speaks with David Smith about his ex-wife’s recent attempt to be released from prison.
Craig Melvin and Josh Mankiewicz go behind the scenes of the making of this episode in ‘Talking Dateline’
Listen on Apple: https://apple.co/3Qp5q7l
Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/6xSyGrJDc8FdlonPPNxwSW
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Brief Summary
Susan Smith confesses to murdering her children, sparking national outrage and ongoing legal battles over her potential parole.
Key points
- A mother's unthinkable crime. The case of Susan Smith reveals a shocking crime that captivated a nation.
- The search for Michael and Alex. A nationwide manhunt ensues for two missing boys, gripping the country.
- A glimmer of hope. A sighting of a boy matching Alex's description brings renewed hope to the search.
- The Investigation Intensifies. Investigators focus on Susan Smith as doubts about her story arise.
- A Shocking Confession. After days of searching, Susan admits to the unthinkable: she killed her children.
- The Trial Begins. Susan Smith's trial captivates the nation as the prosecution presents their case.
Episode highlights
- A mother's unthinkable crimeThe case of Susan Smith reveals a shocking crime that captivated a nation.“A mother's unthinkable crime. A father's unforgettable courage.”1:03Feb 18, 2025
- The search for Michael and AlexA nationwide manhunt ensues for two missing boys, gripping the country.“A nationwide manhunt with a heartbreaking end.”2:07Feb 18, 2025
- A glimmer of hopeA sighting of a boy matching Alex's description brings renewed hope to the search.“A call came into the command center, a sighting of a young boy...”24:07Feb 18, 2025
- The Investigation IntensifiesInvestigators focus on Susan Smith as doubts about her story arise.“Not everything checked out.”27:08Feb 18, 2025
- A Shocking ConfessionAfter days of searching, Susan admits to the unthinkable: she killed her children.“Susan Smith finally told the truth.”37:59Feb 18, 2025
- The Trial BeginsSusan Smith's trial captivates the nation as the prosecution presents their case.“Her handwritten confession made that clear.”46:10Feb 18, 2025
- Susan's Emotional LetterIn a letter, Susan expresses her grief and acknowledges her horrible decision.“I am not a horrible person, Carol. I'm a human being who made a horrible decision.”1:07:24Feb 18, 2025
- David's Heartfelt TestimonyDavid shares his pain and anger during Susan's parole hearing, emphasizing her choice to kill.“This wasn't a tragic mistake. It wasn't something that she didn't mean to do.”1:15:36Feb 18, 2025






