WHO CALLED AMY? | The Amy Mihaljevic Case | Part 2
- Sep 13, 2026
- 55:13
- Full Episode
WHO CALLED AMY?
Amy Mihaljevic /// Part 2 /// Episode: 309
In 1989, 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was lured from a shopping center in Bay Village, Ohio. More than three decades later, one haunting question remains: Who called Amy?
Nic and the Captain revisit one of Northeast Ohio’s most enduring unsolved cases.
Brief Summary
The episode discusses the abduction and murder of Amy Mahalavik, focusing on eyewitness accounts and investigation challenges.
Key points
- Welcome to True Crime Garage. Hosts Nick and Captain introduce the show and thank listeners for tuning in.
- This Week's Featured Beer. The hosts discuss the Pink Drink by Highwire Brewing, a sour ale.
- Eyewitness Accounts. Discussion of composite sketches based on two children's eyewitness accounts of Amy's abductor.
- The Significance of the Abduction Day. The hosts analyze the implications of Amy being abducted on a Friday.
- The Eyewitness Account. An eyewitness claims to have seen a man near the scene before the body was found.
- FBI Involvement. The FBI quickly gets involved in Amy's case, raising questions about the abduction.
Episode highlights
- Welcome to True Crime GarageHosts Nick and Captain introduce the show and thank listeners for tuning in.“It's good to be seen and it's good to see you.”0:52Sep 13, 2026
- This Week's Featured BeerThe hosts discuss the Pink Drink by Highwire Brewing, a sour ale.“If you're looking for a pink drink, you can't miss it.”1:25Sep 13, 2026
- Eyewitness AccountsDiscussion of composite sketches based on two children's eyewitness accounts of Amy's abductor.“It's very rare that this occurrence happens.”3:20Sep 13, 2026
- The Significance of the Abduction DayThe hosts analyze the implications of Amy being abducted on a Friday.“The abductor chose that day. Amy didn't choose that day.”19:21Sep 13, 2026
- The Eyewitness AccountAn eyewitness claims to have seen a man near the scene before the body was found.“Why do you believe that you saw this the night before her body was found?”25:50Sep 13, 2026
- FBI InvolvementThe FBI quickly gets involved in Amy's case, raising questions about the abduction.“This child didn't run away. They went looking for her.”30:21Sep 13, 2026
- Profile of the AbductorA profile of Amy's abductor is created, revealing chilling insights into his character.“He would be uncomfortable with male and female adults.”34:11Sep 13, 2026
- The Unsolved CrimeYears later, the crime remains unsolved, leaving many questions unanswered.“If somebody somewhere can figure out how this individual knew her...”45:51Sep 13, 2026
Tension
65/ 100Some tension
