WHO CALLED AMY? | The Amy Mihaljevic Case | Part 1
- Sep 13, 2026
- 1:01:23
- Full Episode
WHO CALLED AMY?
Amy Mihaljevic /// Part 1 /// Episode: 308 In 1989, 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was lured from a shopping center in Bay Village, Ohio. More than three decades later, one haunting question remains: Who called Amy?
Nic and the Captain revisit one of Northeast Ohio’s most enduring unsolved cases.
Brief Summary
The episode details the abduction and murder of Amy Mahalavik, including eyewitness accounts and investigation findings.
Key points
- The Day Amy Disappeared. On October 27, 1989, 10-year-old Amy Mahalavik went missing after school. Her last known sighting was outside a Baskin-Robbins, where she was approached by a man.
- A Mother's Instinct. Margaret Mahalavik sensed something was wrong when Amy didn’t come home. She rushed to the school and then to the police station to report her missing.
- The Mysterious Phone Call. Before her disappearance, Amy received a call from a man claiming to be a family friend, inviting her on a shopping trip. This detail complicates the investigation.
- Janet's Discovery. Janet Seabold finds a body during her jog, leading to a tragic revelation.
- Autopsy Revelations. The autopsy reveals Amy was brutally murdered, raising questions about the motive.
- New Evidence in Amy's Case. Investigators reveal handmade curtain and blanket found near Amy's body, possibly linked to her murder.
Episode highlights
- The Day Amy DisappearedOn October 27, 1989, 10-year-old Amy Mahalavik went missing after school. Her last known sighting was outside a Baskin-Robbins, where she was approached by a man.“But on this Friday, not everyone will come home.”3:09Sep 13, 2026
- A Mother's InstinctMargaret Mahalavik sensed something was wrong when Amy didn’t come home. She rushed to the school and then to the police station to report her missing.“Margaret tried to get into the school, but no luck.”12:55Sep 13, 2026
- The Mysterious Phone CallBefore her disappearance, Amy received a call from a man claiming to be a family friend, inviting her on a shopping trip. This detail complicates the investigation.“This could have been a bit confusing for Amy.”17:02Sep 13, 2026
- Janet's DiscoveryJanet Seabold finds a body during her jog, leading to a tragic revelation.“I think I found a body. Called the police.”27:32Sep 13, 2026
- Autopsy RevelationsThe autopsy reveals Amy was brutally murdered, raising questions about the motive.“Not only did he confirm that Amy had been murdered, but she had been brutally stabbed.”29:20Sep 13, 2026
- New Evidence in Amy's CaseInvestigators reveal handmade curtain and blanket found near Amy's body, possibly linked to her murder.“Identifying the curtain and blanket could lead investigators to the scene where she was killed.”53:24Sep 13, 2026
- Reward Fund IncreasedThe reward for information leading to Amy's killer has now reached $50,000.53:36Sep 13, 2026
- Frustration with InvestigationThe speaker expresses disappointment over the delayed release of crucial evidence in Amy's case.“I was frustrated at the time. I was happy to learn about the new information.”54:03Sep 13, 2026
Tension
75/ 100High tension
