The Pike County Massacre /// True Crime Garage | Forensic Files

But it's one of those things where it seems like it was yesterday, but it also seems like it's it was a million years
ago. Well, it's one of those stories, too, that at least on the local level here, I mean, eight murders in one night
anywhere is going to be a unique scenario. I mean, Yeah. to take the the human element out of it. It's
it's not it's a rare occurrence, thank God, but here living it, I remember that it was
it was kind of like you're just waiting for information. Waiting for Waiting They're going to tell us something more.
We know they're going to tell us something more. And I remember just kind of getting little bits and pieces of it
daily. And it didn't matter if you were really even hunting for the information,
it would find its way to you somehow. You might be driving somewhere where and hear it pop on the radio.

The Pike County Massacre /// True Crime Garage The Pike County Massacre /// In 2016, eight members of the Rhoden family were murdered execution-style in Pike County, Ohio, across four different homes in one night. The shocking case, known as the Pike County Massacre, was later linked to a custody dispute involving the Wagner family and became one of Ohio’s most notorious criminal cases. #truecrime #ohio #pikecounty

Brief Summary

A local murder case involving eight deaths impacts the community deeply.

Key points

A Rare Occurrence. Eight murders in one night is a shocking and rare event.

Episode quotes

It seems like it was yesterday, but also a million years ago.

0:01WatchApr 27, 2026

More from True Crime Garage TV

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.