Molly Miller & Colt Haynes /// Part 2 /// 682 | Forensic Files

thank you [Music] [Music] thank you welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you're doing thanks for
listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is my friend and yours and we
would like to point out that if you are a thin-skinned grammar nerd well this show might not be for you here is the
captain yeah that's because we never did any book learning it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening
thanks for telling a friend [Music] today we are still sipping on this fine brew from tactical Brewing Company this
one is called hatchback Inferno it's an ESB which typically stands for extra special bitter or extra strong binner
think of a really nice English pale ale with some spice added and some higher quality hops ABV 4.8 percent garage
grade 3 and 3 4 bottle caps out of five and let's toast and share some of our friends here Captain who helped us fill
up the fridge this week first up a big cheers to Mike T in Toronto and a big we like to jib to Melody and Riverside
California and last but certainly not least we have Lydia barsati and Percival Virginia everyone we mentioned they went
to our website and clicked on the Pint glass and that was a donation to The Beer fund and for
that we thank you yeah bwr-u-n beer run go to truecrime garage.com and sign up on our mailing list and if you do so
you'll be in the know and you'll get some promo codes and Colonel that's enough of the blossom
all right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime
[Music] thank you next week we'll mark 10 years since Colt Haynes and Molly Miller have last been
seen or heard from and over the years there has been much speculation as to what could have possibly happened to
these two young people there's been many theories bandied about during this time
a lot of them leading back to the nip family and into other Realms of Love County and love
County Law Enforcement that seems to be corrupt and corrupt during the time that these
two go missing and in fact that's why we believe there was little to no investigation at all in the early years
of this case this is one of the most frustrating cases we have three young individuals
two of those individuals are now on a high-speed chase that leads them to this property
this this high-speed chase is a reoccurring event for old Khan in fact we know of at least
one occasion where he stole a vehicle and during a police pursuit loses police on
a chase fleeing to his family's property and then abandons the stolen vehicle on
the family property in which this vehicle is we know the reports but it wasn't recovered
this vehicle and more importantly where are the charges where's the arrest of this guy and then the charges they don't
exist well where are the people yeah you know not to mention the charges but because we know that
Khan's not missing there's three people in that vehicle that night and two are missing and and
one is not correct and maybe that maybe that guy owes those family members some explanations well he's being protected
by law enforcement you can't make this up not to give too much away there will be
charges in this incident I'm talking about the incident of the stolen vehicle right it's it's known throughout the
county he did this and there's no charges there's no arrest in that matter now in
regard to this matter with Colt and Molly missing Khan says right away I don't know what you're talking about
they weren't with me yeah I might have fled the police but they weren't with me I don't know where
they are I have no clue and we have a sheriff who says a Molly Miller that she's a runaway not my
problem not going to do an investigation and then as we've pointed out several times
before the sheriff is a family member of Khan nip and you know what Khan and several of his other family members are
up to no good at this time and we know this we know this this is fact this is not speculation these people are
breaking the law regularly there's just not there's no consequences for them again I'd have no problem with law
enforcement saying hey my family member wasn't involved you need to report it to this different
County but I'm going to do everything in my power to help you that's what you're paid to do
but it seems like it's not just one member of this family that's a piece of [ __ ] it's approximately four
is my guess here captain out of all the family members there's only four pieces of [ __ ] that I can
confirm 100 you can okay yeah I suspect me we have more could be more but I can only confirm well I I like your honesty
so where are we at in this investigation all right Captain it's been 10 years since anybody's seen
Cole Haynes and Molly Miller and as we said earlier there's been a lot of theories in this case
there's no shortage of theories in this case as to what could have happened to these two individuals right or where
they could be to this day and a lot of this comes from local rumor and local information
and it's weird because in all of these stories we know that a lot of times where there's smoke there is fire but we
also know that not all of these theories can possibly be true but all these theories come about
because somebody told somebody something or I saw this or my friend said that they saw this
so there is some root to each one of these theories coming from the very local level and people that knew all of
these people involved so one of the local theories is that they were injured in the car and possibly killed in the
car accident which that one's very quick to kind of wash away right for several reasons we know the vehicle was found
approximately two weeks after the car chase two weeks after these two individuals go missing there's no signs
of blood in the vehicle no signs that anybody was injured or killed in a vehicle accident and then to top that
off we know for a fact that Cole and Molly were calling people that night and we know this based off of
their phone records right those phone records were pulled by investigators they determined that those phones were
in use throughout the entirety of that night and we have people that spoke multiple
different people that spoke to Molly and Colt after they both say the vehicle was
dead so that one seems pretty easy to move on from but let me throw a little shade at
law enforcement there's a high speed chase you know who it was the people that he was with have
been reported missing and it takes you two weeks to find the vehicle shame on you again that goes
back to how much were they really looking for because love county has jurisdiction here and it's not their
problem as the sheriff stated it's not his problem yeah a lot of people have different theories
on why both of the phones may have died or were turned off at the same time think about just that statement
if they are turned off around the same time well there's a big clue that something terrible happened right these
two people who are calling multiple people for help time and time again throughout that night are not just going
to go you know what would be a good idea right now let's both turn off our phones
yeah that doesn't seem like a good thing so if we don't know because those phones
have never been recovered if they were shut off or if they died or what happened to those phones
there is a thought in a theory and maybe this stems from what the sheriff said at the Genesis of this case
that Molly is a runaway and so there are some theories out there that the two of them decided to run away
together again it would seem very strange that for hours that night they're calling
people saying that they need help bring water I've broken my leg right uh it wouldn't be the most it wouldn't be
completely out of the realm of possibility but it seems incredibly unlikely that they would go to those
lengths to kind of stage an opportunity for the two of them to walk away and walk away from what right they neither
of them really have to their [ __ ] together we know that colt is trying to he's on again and off again clean
and we know that Molly is trying to be helped by her family and who knows this could have just been
a phase for Molly right it could have been a phase for her something that she may have grown out of or with a little
bit of help or the right guidance been able to move on from so it doesn't stand to reason to me to
show a lot of evidence that they had a lot of things to walk away from that they're just going to go right off into
the sunset and start up this beautiful life together they don't even have a vehicle
they don't have money they have no means or resources of leaving and starting a new life well not
to mention if that information on the call is correct we have one individual with broken leg correct one Theory and
this is one of the more scary ones and this actually comes from a tip that was called in
once the two were missing and I haven't reported that the tip came in in July so
this could be within days of them going missing or a few weeks because they went
missing in the early part of July but the tip comes in saying that Molly was being held against her will and was tied
to a tree this vehicle or sorry the tree somewhere along Long Hollow Road down in
the woods and this one is this tip unfortunately is a tip that has led to a lot of
emotional turmoil for her family obvious for obvious reasons that something happened to Colt but this tip
only specifically references Molly being held against her will and may have been
tied to a tree at one point and again Long Hollow Road all all signs keep pointing to Long
Hollow Road into the nip property again it doesn't make a lot of sense you have two people missing and it takes you two
weeks to find a vehicle and how quickly were these rumors about her being chained to a tree when you hear those
rumors in your law enforcement you have the nerve to say it's not your problem so the vehicle thing here's one thing I
have to wonder and I don't have confirmation of this but as we said Khan had borrowed that vehicle it was his
girlfriend's vehicle right so what we do know happens is that she files a stolen
vehicle Report the morning after this car chase this may have started a domino effect
that led to finding that vehicle because she files a stolen stolen vehicle Report also files an insurance
claim well you know that eighteen thousand dollars of damage is done to the vehicle so she wants the insurance
company to pay for it it wasn't in her possession at the time I guess not her problem right uh but
other things not people's problems she she well she ends up getting charged with file filing a false a fraudulent
Insurance claim because she let her boyfriend borrow the vehicle it was not stolen but again she probably thought
she'd just get away with it because he's connected to the law enforcement and they're not doing [ __ ] about [ __ ] and
then unfortunately Captain there are dozens and dozens and dozens of theories that all are roughly about the same
meaning but they have different detailed information to them so a lot of these theories are based around
the idea that the two of them were killed out there that night or later um and then where the variance comes
into play is where their remains are or how they were killed or why they were killed but
rather than go through every single one of those in detail I think we can kind of sum them all up here with this
statement that there's the theory that they were killed at some point for reasons undetermined
and that their body locations The Remains are in places unknown Parts Unknown right and to be clear here
though with these theories they all involve different people as being responsible for the murders
or why the murders would be committed in the first place now of those people that
are referenced in these different theories we do have of course James Khan nip who seems like an obvious
person to suspect people in the nip family the sheriff is referenced in some of these theories as either having
involvement or knowledge of the murders and possibly where the bodies are we have again I can't I can't go into it
enough that it's the nip family but there there are certain people named in this that are in the nip family as
possibly being involved either with or without Khan in committing the murders now as far as why they were killed there
is well maybe they saw something they shouldn't have or we're covering something up or this is due to a prior
beef between Colt and Khan uh or that there's a drug operation there I mean there's endless reasons why or
possibilities as to why and then when it comes down to well where would the remains be
if this in fact is true that murder is what we were actually talking about here well that kind of runs the gamut as well
because we have things as simple as well the bodies must be on the knit property
because that would make a whole lot of sense the bodies are in a nearby lake Moxley
lake is actually referenced in these theories which is very close to the knit property
uh but we also have as far as Texas that the bodies are are somewhere in Texas and that would stand and make some sense
too because if you want to cover something up if you want to try to hide a crime and
you you go outside of yours your county line is not a bad idea but also going out
across state line is not a bad idea either and we know that love county is right there on the
border right so Texas would make a whole lot of sense if you are trying to dispose of conceal and hide something
that you do not want anyone else to find but again law enforcement in this family
why wouldn't they do everything in their power to search for these individuals we have
scent dogs they could have used they could use cadaver dogs why wasn't this done
so one of the strangest theories or the perpetrator of this theory that I find to be incredibly strange
and I want to bring it up here now so we can move on from it one of the theories is that yes they
were killed out there and their bodies disposed of but the perpetrator the murderer is
Colt's brother Jesse and the reason why this Theory comes about is that it's it's either rumor or
maybe it's fact I've not talked to anybody that says that they heard this happen
but it said that on at least one occasion Jesse threatened his brother uh with a knife or threatened to stab
him at some point um we do know that they did not get together they did not get along very
well uh but but here's the problem I have with that theory Jesse is not one of the names mentioned
of anybody that that colt called that night so it's very difficult for me to try to
wrap my head around the idea that they're in a vehicle with con nip they end this police chase on Khan's family's
property they're trapped out in the middle of nowhere he's got a broken leg they're calling everybody else other
than Jesse for help and that so what happens Jesse magically shows up he's the only one that finds him and
decides to kill them right and and their and their bodies have never been found so that does not
make a whole lot of sense to me I think there are people that have already been named in this story that make a whole
lot more sense as to what very likely happened in the situation I have to remember that Molly is connected to this
family she she's known her family has known the knit family for a very long time in fact reported that it would be
probably the entirety of Molly's life one of the things I think is so fascinating with this case is that the
timeline is it's very long it's very extensive and like we said we from that day from the the
from the day that they were a part of that police chase nobody has spoken to or seen Molly or
cult but we have a very interesting 9-1-1 call that happens I believe eight months
after they go missing yes and this will give this will add some weight to that theory that maybe they were killed and
disposed of in Moxley Lake that there that one or both bodies may be in that body of water
so this 9-1-1 call comes in eight months after the two go missing the call is from a man's phone and his name is Colby
Barrick okay well he is Khan's uncle and it's believed by the person by the emergency Personnel
that received the call that this was an accidental phone call that it was a pocket dial 2911 right and it's recorded
so Colby Barrack's phone calls 9-1-1 and the the person that here's the call picks up
is it you know hello what's your emergency but there's nobody talking to emergency personnel
they just hear talking because again it's it's a likely a pocket dial right so the emergency
Personnel operator says that look from the sounds of it this sounds like somebody describing how
Molly and Colt were allegedly murdered so from the from the recording and uh for obvious reasons I'm going to
choose to use some other words here but I'll give it to you verbatim you'll be able to you'll be able to figure it out
uh the words I'm changing so what can be heard is it says that someone's talking
when the phone picks up and you can hear the person saying you know you're effing mad you know you're
effing tired everything what [ __ ] yes um I'm not supposed to guess oh I thought you wanted me to guess the
word I was talking to the list I was just joking you know you're effing mad you know you're effing tired effing
Moxley Lake a buck knife Molly Miller they shot him in the mouth right there I can put my finger all the way through it
now it's been said that this is in the voice of Barrick of Colby Barrick it's coming from his phone right and I know
that this sounds like they're not complete sentences this is just what people say they can make out
in in the Rants and Raves and the conversation that's going on that they can hear
so where the parts are that don't make sense and where it sounds a little choppy there there's other words being
spoken that they just cannot figure out what what's being said it's muffled right
so the operator says they hear Kobe Barracks saying Colby Barracks saying you know you're effing mad you know
you're effing tired effing Moxley Lake references a knife references a shot to the mouth yeah and the operator says
that they also heard splashing water splashing and a gunshot or two gunshots and then
the phone it the line disconnects so the operator then runs to sheriff Russell and says hey there's this pocket
dial 9-1-1 call that just came in they're talking about I believe they're talking about Molly Miller and Colt
Haynes who are missing and it sounds like they're talking about one or both of them being murdered
and something about water yeah being thrown into the lake or a pond and what's weird here and this is
recorded as well Joe Russell says Oh you mean Moxley Lake it he doesn't need a whole lot of more
information to know exactly the area that the caller may have been referencing right and what's interesting
about that though too is later so this call is pinged right because it comes into 9-1-1
and they determine that the general area where this phone call came from was a pond that is just North of Long Hollow
Road on Oswalt Road and so the phone ping confirms that not only is this caller talking about
Moxley Lake but the phone calls coming from an area very near Moxley Lake [Music]
[Music] all right well we are back again one of the most frustrating cases and and it never never ceases to amaze
me I guess that uh We've almost 700 episodes and then we find a crazy case like this where it's why
isn't this case been talked about more often well you get you get a poor drug area an area that is just overrun with
drugs and a small population and it only takes a few bad apples to create a very bad situation
and what I think we have here Captain is just that in in that bad situation in my
opinion my humble garage opinion started at the top with with the sheriff and think about the sheriff very few people
can can take the sheriff out of office it's very limited who can remove a Sheriff from office
so in some sense the sheriff in a lot of ways is the king of the county he's one of the top dogs
but in this situation with Sheriff Joe Russell he is the definition of the fox guarding
the hen house and we know this because later he would eventually be removed as Sheriff and charged
they bring him up on criminal charges now unfortunately he gets a sweetheart deal
uh I don't I wouldn't even call it a slap on the wrist because he he gets no jail time
he gets unsupervised probation which I feel like most of us are all on unsupervised probation isn't that what
life is just just 70 years of unsupervised probation I need to be supervised uh and he pays but here's
where he does pay the piper Captain he gets a 370 dollar fine he had to pay 370 dollars for his
misdeeds well what were his misdeeds so uh this is a pretty lengthy story uh he gets charged with four different charges
he and look we know he's guilty because the court found him guilty because he pled
no contest he basically says yeah you caught me I don't really have a good defense here
um I will plead no contest in trade for this sweetheart deal it's four charges I'm a little confused here I'll be
perfectly clear with you because it sounds to me like maybe one or two of the charges he actually pled guilty to
um but we get a very summarized version of the report of of those Court hearings
what happened is this living in Sheriff Joe Russell's home is his son and his son is involved in a meth drug
operation in fact his son has a girlfriend a woman living there at the sheriff's house with
him there's drugs in that home that the sheriff lives in and the woman that's living there with
them is a fugitive she has warrants out for her arrest in multiple counties including love County
she's living in love County Sheriff's home so not hard to find her what happens is this woman who later
gets arrested after she's arrested she tells police look I lived in this home and everybody
knew that she was living there like a lot a lot of people knew that she was living there she she told people that I
was reminded regularly by the sheriff of what a safe haven is that if I leave his son
if I leave this home I'll be arrested on those warrants that are outstanding on me
what happens she leaves the Sun goes and Shacks up with another guy guess what happens
knock knock on the door she's arrested all right Sheriff Joe Russell serves the warrant
on her arrest her and arrest the man she's living with because he's harboring a fugitive right you can't make this
stuff up right it's like uh okay well you should have done that with your son so later it's proven that his son is
involved in a drug operation and that one of two things one of a couple things happened this this is the gray areas
either Sheriff Joe Russell was involved in this drug operation that was going on
in his home that his home was involved in or he turned a blind eye to it or was aware of it and may have just
covered it up you know the the there's no way the sheriff didn't know that this drug
operation is going on inside his home or involves his home and part of that story involves con nip
his relative that his son the sheriff's son and their relative con nip were all involved in
trafficking methamphetamine and we again the son the sheriff's son ends up being charged and convicted
later Khan nip would be charged on several charges but one of the charges includes
it's stemming from that police chase on the night that colt Haynes and Molly Miller go missing because
everybody knows that he that he gave Chase to the police everybody knows he was involved in that
he's not charged with this until the sheriff becomes in trouble until the sheriff is
he was actually suspended with pay for a while but once the sheriff is suspended
now Khan nip can face charges on crimes that he's committed while his relative was the sheriff right
so this this whole thing is called coming crumbling down around the nip family and Sheriff Joe Russell
Colby Barrick who we've already referenced he's the one that did the butt dial to 9-1-1 making incriminating
statements about what may have happened to Molly Miller uh in 2018 he was arrested on unrelated
Firearms charges and sentenced to 46 months in prison while in custody he allegedly told law
enforcement that Molly Miller and Colt haynes's bodies are in a pond are located in a pond now some people have
taken that to mean Moxley Lake to be perfectly clear Moxley lake is not on that nip family property right
there is a pond on the nip family property so I don't know based off of those statements again those are alleged
statements I can't say 100 that they are true but what I can why isn't this being searched
the knit family will not allow law enforcement to search their their very large property that's the short of it so
what we have here Captain is a couple of problems over the years thankfully people that care agencies that care have
gotten involved but they've run into a lot of speed bumps and roadblocks along the way so Oklahoma State Bureau of
Investigation OSBI got involved in this case years after the two go missing they
investigate and based off of everything they find they they have changed this to
from a missing person's case to a homicide case they're saying their investigation has
led them to believe that Molly Miller has been killed and very likely Colt Haynes has been killed as well these are
homicides not missing people the FBI has been involved a little bit maybe at an arm's length it's very
difficult for me to to say it seems like they very recently got involved which tells me that this case is still very
active from a investigation standpoint and that it's finally truly being investigated the major roadblock is that
they've not been able to search the nip property they've searched areas near there
anytime you know the rumors come up that the bodies could be here or there they search where they're able
to but they've not been able to search the nip property without a search warrant
the roadblock seems to be that the D.A will not sign off on a search warrant request for that property
and the nips ain't letting anybody in there which makes no sense because of that that butt dial 9-1-1 call you would
think that would be all the evidence you need to open up a search of that property so let me tell you how this
case gets solved there's three ways that you could solve this case number one would be remains
or the the remains of both or or one of these individuals to be recovered why because if we have one or two sets of
remains that are recovered and it's Colt Haynes and Miller Molly Miller this will confirm someone's story
right there's all these people out there that have reported things to law enforcement over the years I heard this
I heard that my cousin told me this my friend witnessed this and told me this what will happen is when you find those
bodies there will be evidence as well and now we will know for certain it's a homicide case and there will be evidence
that will very likely confirm someone's story out there and now you have a direct lead
on a story that should lead you to your perpetrator or perpetrators the other way is to summons a grand jury
hearing this is if no remains are found we can get some evidence or at least in the
form of many different people telling many different stories on the stand testifying in front of a grand jury
about what they have heard or what they may have witnessed themselves or conversations they had that night with
Colt or Molly or Khan and Khan's family this would be considered evidence and could lead you to other people that have
additional information and with some of these people being locked up so unfortunately Khan from my
understanding has served his time and he's out now uh I'm uncertain on Kobe Barrick if he's
been released yet I don't believe he has but with some of these people being locked up maybe some people that may
have once been scared to talk are not so scared anymore or at the very least with
the sheriff not being in power anymore maybe they feel free to tell us what they've seen or what they heard
the other way would be in my opinion Captain a new D.A because it was the D.A that would not
sign off on the search warrant request and this is a search warrant that should have been requested and should have been
granted in my humble opinion and yeah it seems like a no-brainer there's some pretty powerful statements in
information and evidence in this search warrant request that I think will have people scratching
their heads going why was this search warrant not granted and the nip property searched
because we could have all of our answers if they searched that property especially if they find something well
what is that information that's in the search warrant request okay so the request here Captain is that that large
property the nip family property uh please grant us a search warrant for that property and you know
that they have to list what it is that they are looking for right well the property to be seized in this situation
is we have an officer stating that they believe that in the nip family property the
human remains of cult Haynes and Molly Miller will be found there and it's a deputy with love County
Sheriff's Office that filed this with the D.A an attempt to get a search warrant for this property and some of
the facts supporting a probable cause to search this property are as follows the document States July 7th 2013 and
approximately 22-46 hours Wilson Oklahoma police officers Richard parsley and Brandon
Dingman began a vehicle Pursuit with a 2012 Honda Accord that goes on to give the license plate that's not necessary
for our story The Pursuit continued South in Carter County and entered love County Law Enforcement lost contact with
the vehicle on Long Hollow Road in love County Wilson Police lost sight of the vehicle however the vehicle was located
again by a love County Sheriff's unit but contact was lost again on Long Hollow Road so they're giving us a very
brief description of that car chase now the reason why we've got to for the sake
of getting this document getting the search warrant we've got to put the two people we're looking for on that
property this document does this that's why I don't understand why it wasn't signed off on
the first statement it says stormy McPeak will testify that she overheard the Pursuits start while monitoring the
scanner old stormy and she communicated to another individual and confirmed that
colt and Khan were in the that vehicle together Josh Davis can testify that Molly Miller
and Colt Haynes were at his residence on that night he observed a Honda Accord arrive at his as his residence Colt
Haynes entered the residence and was there to pick up Molly Miller he watched Haynes get into the front
passenger seat Molly get into the rear passenger seat this was about 15 minutes before receiving the text from stormy
saying that there's a police chase going on so that puts those two in that vehicle
two different people putting the our victims in that vehicle that night we have another person Jessica Williams
can testify that she knew Molly and Colt were passengers in the pursuit of that vehicle and that both Miller and Haynes
stated that Khan nip was the driver Daniel Eppley can testify that he received a call from Molly Miller in the
early morning hours of Sunday July 8th reporting that she and Colt Haynes were lost in the woods at an unknown location
after being involved in a police chase in which cotton nip was the driver Epley goes on to say that they attempted
to locate them but could not find a positive location here we go captain four people
Rob Nichols Devin Johnson Colby Turner Benita long drove out to Long Hollow and Pike roads
to find Haynes after his desperate pleas for water and assistance when they could
not locate Haynes Cole Haynes advised them to travel to Khan nip's grandfather's
residence located on Long Hollow Road in ascon where he left the two of them Colt said quote that [ __ ] knows
where we are at the four drove to that location and end an encountered Khan and his Aunt
Jennifer knip there on the front porch of the residents Khan walked out to the fence
that separates the driveway from the front porch and we have Nichols who had an active
phone call with Colt Haynes Nichols is on the phone with Colt Haynes while Colt Haynes is lost in the middle of the
woods with Molly Miller right he's standing directly in front of Khan nip Colt is demanding to talk to Khan nip
because Khan is telling them yeah I don't know where they are I don't know what they're talking about
I don't know I don't know what's going on this young man hands the phone to con nip
con nip walks away the people there the four people we just mentioned can hear Colt Haynes screaming
at Khan on that phone as he's walking away with that phone Khan attempts to act as if he knows
nothing Haynes is screaming for con for Khan to give back the phone to his friend
Khan hands the phone back to this young man and this is what he says to those four
people that were out there looking for Colt Haynes and Molly Miller quote do you remember where the Mustang
was they are close to that end quote remember we talked about that Ford Mustang a silver Ford Mustang that Khan had
driven months prior right and abandoned on the knit property I guess this is close to the same area
that he says that he left them so he's saying all night I don't know what you're talking about I wasn't with them
but then after that phone call emits to it says you remember where that Mustang was that's where they're at and hands
back the phone I mean this guy is a psychopath to top that off we know that the Oklahoma
Highway Patrol obtained a court order for phone records for con nip Molly Miller and Colt Haynes and using
Cellular Tower information from those phones and activities on that on those phones that night they can put the three
of them together at all times relevant to uh to that police chase the three phones were all in love County
together at times after the vehicle was lost by love County deputies on Long Hollow Road right
Molly Miller and Colt Haynes both called numerous people who were interviewed that night
trying to get help saying that Khan nip had abandoned them and abandoned the vehicle and that the
two of them were both lost in the woods and Colt was in a creek lying in a creek
because he had broke his leg well and I think these friends of theirs the ones that they called The Night of the
high-speed chase the night of them gone missing are some of the best eyewitnesses that we have yes and
and for them to then go to the police and say well he he first tells us Khan first tells us I don't know what you're
talking about and then later says well this is where you can find them again why law enforcement didn't do
anything and and we we have to be clear there's two counties the one County that you call you go well
the the the the sheriff the says it's not my problem well it's not your problem because you're connected to the
individual and you probably actually know how they went missing and if you actually investigate it well
maybe your whole family goes to jail but the other County why aren't they knocking on doors
well that's the problem so that the town of Wilson their Police Department as well as Carter County
they're really limited if if in fact these two individuals were killed in in concealed right in love County
these other agencies are limited based off of jurisdiction as to what they can do
if if the two individuals were killed in in the town of Wilson and concealed there
or killed in the county of Carter and concealed there these and these agencies would be able to fully
investigate this again where the roadblock lies and where where the biggest problem with
this case is that where I think that these bodies are is protected by this family's property
line you're not allowed to come onto this property and you're not allowed to search this property
and if that's in fact where they've been concealed all this time we're never going to get any answers
until that property is searched and that's why I pointed out that the three ways to get that property to be searched
would be grand jury hearings or new D.A because remember the D.A would not sign off on
the search warrant I went through the problem the the information and the evidence that the that law enforcement
is stating here's why we we have probable cause to search this this area right and the D.A goes not not good
enough come back with something more well you have two people that have not been seen in 10 years and everything
points to the last time that they were breathing and talking to other people that they
were on this family's property look this does not seem like a difficult case no but at all there are people out
there that that shame on them there are people out there bad people that have made this a very difficult case
foreign [Music] thank everybody for joining us here in the garage if you need more True Crime
garage check out our bonus content on our website store or through the Apple podcast app Colonel do we have any
recommended reading for the beautiful listeners this week I am very excited to recommend to all of you James renner's
new book little crazy children a true crime tragedy for long time listeners of this show you will remember the Lisa
Pruitt case Lisa was a teenage girl who was killed in Shaker Heights Ohio back in September of 1990. we did a six-part
series titled Shaker Heights back in February of 2020. this was a dramatization created from real police
interview transcripts straight from the Shaker Heights Police Department's file on this case well now James Renner has
written and released the definitive true crime story about the murder case this is a murder that many believe they know
who kill buildly support and I'm reading this now as it just came out and I'm interested to see the different angles
in which James examines this murder case it's a horrible crime that rocked the affluent neighborhood of Shaker Heights
Ohio check out little crazy children a true crime Tragedy by James Renner you can find that great title and many more
on our recommended page on truecrime garage.com and until next week be good be kind
[Music] [Applause] thank you

Molly Miller & Colt Haynes /// Part 2 /// 682

Part 2 of 2

www.TrueCrimeGarage.com (http://www.truecrimegarage.com/)

July 7th, 2013 - 17 year old Molly Miller and 21 year old Colt Haynes had just met about a 10 days prior when they meet up for a night with others at a party. Molly and Colt leave the house party with a local guy that they both know. His name is James Conn Nipp. Nipp is known well in the area by both civilians and members of local law enforcement. Nipp decided to piss off the police. He was practically begging them for a high speed chase, something he had done several times before. After the police chase Nipp goes home. Molly and Colt have not been seen since. Grab a beer and cool down in the Garage with Nic and the Captain. Happy 4th of July!

Beer of the Week - Hatchback Inferno by Tactical Brewing Company

Garage Grade - 3 and 3 quarter bottle caps out of 5

Brief Summary

Colt Haynes and Molly Miller vanished in 2013, with local corruption hindering the investigation into their disappearance.

Key points

10 Years of Mystery. Next week marks 10 years since Colt Haynes and Molly Miller disappeared under suspicious circumstances.
The High-Speed Chase. A high-speed chase leads to a family's property, raising questions about law enforcement's actions.
The 9-1-1 Call. A pocket dial reveals chilling details about the alleged murder of Molly and Colt.
Sheriff Joe Russell's Controversy. Sheriff Joe Russell faces scrutiny as he is linked to a drug operation in his own home.
The Missing Persons Case Turns Homicide. Investigators shift the case of Molly Miller and Colt Haynes from missing persons to homicide.
The Search Warrant Dilemma. Law enforcement struggles to obtain a search warrant for the Nip family property, hindering the investigation.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

You can't make this up.

4:44WatchJul 5, 2023

Tension

75/ 100High tension

More from True Crime Garage TV

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.