Episode 720: The Kidnapping of J. Paul Getty III
- Oct 29, 2025
- 1:21:21
- Full Episode
Throughout the twentieth century, few names loomed as large in the business and financial worlds as John Paul Getty. Once the richest man in the world, Getty made his fortune in the oil industry and an avid art collector, with a massive collection that served as a basis for the Getty Museum, the wealthiest museum in the world. Getty’s wealth and business acumen made him a household name well beyond his death in 1976; however, that same wealth and notoriety made him a target for con artists and other criminals. Among those who sought to extort the Getty family, no attempt was more incredible and sensational than the kidnapping of Getty’s favorite grandchild, J. Paul Getty III, by an Italian crime syndicate in 1973. At first, the scion of the Getty family refused to negotiate with kidnappers, arguing that, if he paid the money, they would only kidnap other members of this family. But Getty reconsidered his position just a few weeks later, when his grandson’s ear arrived in the mail, with the promise of other body parts, should he not comply with their demands. References Associated Press. 1973. "Getty kidnapers spurn offer of $430,000 ransom as 'paltry'." Buffalo Nerws (Buffalo, NY), August 3: 2. —. 1973. "Getty's mother awaits word from kidnapers on ransom." Buffalo News (Buffalo, NY), July 18: 3. —. 1973. "Grandson of Getty missing." Los Angeles Times, July 13: 9. —. 1974. "Italy arrests 3, seeks 4th in Getty kidnapping ." New York Times, Janaury 17: 14. Miller, Julie. 2017. "What All the Money in the World gets right (and wrong) about the Getty kidnapping." Vanity Fair, December 25. New York Times. 1976. "2 Getty kidnappers sentenced in Italy." New York Times, January 30: 10. —. 1973. "Roman police report a threat to sever a finger of Getty boy." New York Times, July 20: 2. Norman, Judith. 2013. "His favorite wife: A memoir looks back on the life of the fifth and final Mrs. Getty." New York Times, September 1: 10. Pearson, John. 1995. Painfully Rich: J. Paul Getty and His Heirs. London, UK: Macmillan. Reuters. 1973. "Ransom is offered for Paul Getty, 17, his father reports." New York Times, November 18: 8. Cowritten by Alaina Urquhart, Ash Kelley & Dave White (Since 10/2022) Produced & Edited by Mikie Sirois (Since 2023) Research by Dave White (Since 10/2022), Alaina Urquhart & Ash Kelley Listener Correspondence & Collaboration by Debra Lally Listener Tale Video Edited by Aidan McElman (Since 6/2025)
Brief Summary
The episode discusses the kidnapping of J. Paul Getty III and his grandfather's indifference to the ransom demands.
Key points
- Spooky Season Begins. The hosts set the stage for a spooky-themed episode, blending true crime with Halloween vibes.
- The Kidnapping of J. Paul Getty III. A deep dive into the shocking kidnapping case of J. Paul Getty III, exploring family dynamics and emotional detachment.
- The Lonely Childhood of Paul Getty. Paul Getty's upbringing was marked by a lack of affection and celebration, leading to deep emotional voids.
- Paul Getty's Academic Success. Despite a troubled upbringing, Paul Getty excelled academically, becoming fluent in multiple languages.
- John Getty's Downward Spiral. John Getty's life unraveled due to drug addiction and a tumultuous relationship with his father.
- The Rise of Indrangetta. Indrangetta evolved from petty crimes to serious criminal activities, including kidnapping and murder.
Episode highlights
- Spooky Season BeginsThe hosts set the stage for a spooky-themed episode, blending true crime with Halloween vibes.“It's spooky season and we usually do spooky stuff.”0:41Oct 29, 2025
- The Kidnapping of J. Paul Getty IIIA deep dive into the shocking kidnapping case of J. Paul Getty III, exploring family dynamics and emotional detachment.“Imagine just being indifferent to your grandchild's kidnapping.”13:02Oct 29, 2025
- The Lonely Childhood of Paul GettyPaul Getty's upbringing was marked by a lack of affection and celebration, leading to deep emotional voids.“It's like, you don't need to be a hugger of other people.”18:25Oct 29, 2025
- Paul Getty's Academic SuccessDespite a troubled upbringing, Paul Getty excelled academically, becoming fluent in multiple languages.“He was a book guy.”20:24Oct 29, 2025
- John Getty's Downward SpiralJohn Getty's life unraveled due to drug addiction and a tumultuous relationship with his father.“Oh, that's sad.”29:57Oct 29, 2025
- The Rise of IndrangettaIndrangetta evolved from petty crimes to serious criminal activities, including kidnapping and murder.“They were committing petty crimes like a little dabble of racketeering.”35:44Oct 29, 2025
- Gail Getty's DesperationGail Getty's frantic search for help after her son's kidnapping reveals her isolation.“I felt utterly alone and I had to figure out what in God's name I should do.”41:37Oct 29, 2025
- Paul's PleaIn a letter, Paul urged his family to pay the ransom quickly for his safety.“Pay up. I beg you, pay up as soon as possible if you wish me well.”47:40Oct 29, 2025






