Jennifer Medernach /// Part 1 /// 532 | Forensic Files

thank you [Music] [Music] welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you're doing thanks for
listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always it's my friend and yours guard
that plate because he's tasting those curly fries here is the cat I always love it when you order curly fries but
you get one onion ring it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening thanks for foreign
[Music] this week we are very excited to be featuring hazy Jane New England IPA by
one of our favorites Brew dog this is a New England IPA retuned in Scotland and left unfiltered for a hazy appearance
and smooth delivery dry hopped with pineapple mango and a hint of zesty lime garage grade 4 and a quarter bottle caps
out of five and here's some big cheers to our friends who helped us out with this week's beer fun first up a cheers
to Tiffany in Alabama and big shout out to Brooke in Benton Arkansas here's a big cheers to Angie and Vinnie and
Bonita Springs Florida and the big we like your trip to Catherine and Tucson Arizona here's a triple cheers Captain
to Kai logs and D up in big beautiful Saskatoon Saskatchewan Canada and last but certainly not least we have Miss
Sarah in Shetland Scotland everyone we just mentioned went to truecrime garage.com and they helped us out with
plug in the holes in the old beer fridge and for that we are grateful big shout out to the big d b w e double r u n Beer
Run make sure you subscribe to the podcast make sure you tell a friend make sure you share it with people on social
media and that is enough of the business all right everybody gather around grab a
chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music]
[Music] this week on True Crime garage a 14 year old girl goes missing her parents call police police often
write missing teens off as Runaways but in this case she pretty much was a runaway
but then she turned up dead a victim of a very violent homicide this teen girl was gone for days and
then thrown over a bridge detectives say her body was dumped there but she was not killed there
under her body investigators found what they believe was the murder weapon this was just one of several pieces of
evidence collected from the body recovery scene evidence the Clay County Sheriff's
Office still has and is resubmitting for DNA testing some evil monster simply discarded her
like trash and no one is talking but why was she the victim of a serial killer did she become just another young girl
in a string of victims or did she fall prey to someone closer to home this is true crime garage
this is the case of Jennifer medernick [Music] in 2001 14 year old Jennifer metternack
was living in Woodland Estates Mobile Home Park this was a large mobile home park situated on 103rd Street in
Jacksonville Florida which is in Duval County Florida it's not one of those parks where people bring their campers
this is a development with a nice sign at the entrance establish smaller homes and really a community type of feel as
of earlier this year 2021 the park had 293 residents so it is quite large now Jennifer lived at 9359 103rd Street on
lot 28 with her mother Angie metternak it's not clear where her Father James was living at this time he may have been
living with them or how much of a role he played in her life as he's simply absent from all of the stories and the
news articles that I could find Jennifer was a student at Joseph Stillwell middle
school but at 14 years old she was starting to behave a little like an older Teenager her mom later said that
Jennifer used to be a good girl but that changed in the spring of 2001. this would be right around the time the
Jennifer turned 14 years old she says Jennifer started to act out she began cutting school and so on Angie said as
quoted in the Florida Times Union quote she started going downhill last year at the end of the school year she had to go
to summer school she started getting into a little trouble now three weeks before everything happened everything
being what we're leading up to here Captain Jennifer got a ticket because she was caught smoking at school
so as you can imagine Jennifer and her mom started butting heads as often happens with teen girls and their
mothers and over the weekend of November 3rd and 4th 2001 Jennifer and her mom had a big argument now according to Mom
according to Angie the two had words over the state of Jennifer's room it was such a mess that her things were
spilling out into the hallway now Angie later told the Florida Times Union that on that Sunday November 4th the two
worked together to clean up the room and afterward Jennifer was allowed to go out
to hang with some friends and at that time Jennifer left with a girlfriend someone her mother did not know as she
was told Jennifer and her friend were going to walk to the safari food store this is a convenience store located on
103rd Street in West Jacksonville this is very near the Woodland Estates where Jennifer lived so this is a rather short
walk it would have taken the two just a few minutes to get there on foot Angie said Jennifer kissed her goodbye and
told her that she loved her now that's the nice version of the story and if that's what Mom says happened well
unless you're Casey Anthony or a few other moms that we've discussed here on the show then we will go with that we
will go with what you're saying but I do want to take this quick moment here to present a slightly different and maybe
still possible series of events because we've seen this too many times maybe Mom and Jennifer have some type of
blow up argument and in typical teen girl fashion Jennifer storms off to meet up with her friend and because she left
in a tizzy Jennifer took nothing with her she left the trailer on Sunday and then
she did not come home that Sunday night now even though she didn't come home that night we still believe that she was
alive and well and just staying at a friend's house yes Captain so I took that time to do a little aside and add
in my two cents here because later it was reported that it was not uncommon for Jennifer to spend the night out at a
friend's house this especially after mom and daughter argued so when she didn't return that Sunday night her mom
probably wasn't too worked up about it she probably decided to let Jennifer cool off for a bit but Jennifer didn't
come home on Monday night either so this is not what you think right as you pointed out Captain Jennifer was
still okay even after two nights not at home she was choosing not to go home she
was being a stubborn little teenager is what she was yeah she was still at the Woodland Estates just not at her own
house where she stayed Sunday night we don't know for certain and her mother didn't know either
Jennifer did not have a cell phone so her mom could not reach her or track her movements Jennifer apparently hung
around the neighborhood on Sunday night and Monday and this will come from other
Witnesses statements as we said her mom had been struggling with Jennifer cutting school and sure enough Jennifer
failed to show up at school on Monday but she was still in the area several residents in the mobile home park later
told police that Jennifer told them on Monday that she had a fight with her mother and that she had left home she
did not say where she was staying or whether she planned on leaving Woodland Estates or not meanwhile Jennifer's
mother apparently decided that enough is enough although Jennifer had never run away from home before she had
temporarily left in the past but Jennifer never stayed away for what was turning out to be this long it seems
that her mom knew that Jennifer was defiantly staying away from home and wanted to call in some Rand enforcements
to help her Corral her rebellious teenager she reported Jennifer missing to the Duval County Sheriff's Office on
Monday night clearly she felt that Jennifer needed you know a talking to and perhaps maybe
even a a little scare from someone in a position of authority because after she filed the missing persons report on
Monday evening at 6 PM it's reported that Angie Jennifer's mom caught a glimpse of Jennifer walking in the
distance still with inside the park and we know that another neighbor saw Jennifer at this time as well walking
away from her home but even though Angie could briefly see her daughter she could
not go after her now Angie from my understanding was in poor health at this time and she was not able to get around
very easily so this prevented her from going after her daughter one also probably one of the reasons she called
for help correct but it is interesting to note that this sighting of Jennifer did not prompt Angie to cancel
that missing persons report that she had previously filed Angie either wanted or likely felt that
she needed interveners right AKA police or sheriff's deputies to force the 14 year old to return home and probably you
know tell her to go easy on her mom my friend Jessica submitted a request for the missing persons report and the
request was granted so here is what that report said on November 5th 2001 at 807
PM I was dispatched not me your friendly Colonel but the officer writing the report obviously was dispatched to a
missing person runaway call at 93.59 103rd Street upon my arrival I met with the complainant who is the victim's
mother she stated that the victim wanted to go to the store with one of her friends on
November 4th at 3 30 in the afternoon she told the victim that she could go when the victim did not return she
started checking with some of her neighbors to find out if they had seen the victim on November 5th at 6 PM she
saw the victim in their trailer park she said the victim ran from her and she is in poor health and was unable to go
after the victim the complainant stated that this is not the first time that the
victim has not returned home when she was supposed to she said this is the first time that she has ever stayed gone
this long and that is why she called the police to report the victim missing the
complainant believes that the victim is staying with someone in the trailer park
possibly another unknown girl that she saw the victim with today the complainant said this is the first time
she has called the police to report the victim as missing so this report specifies that Jennifer was last seen
wearing brown sandals green and black shorts and a white T-shirt with red lips some kind of drawing or decal of red
lips on this white T-shirt she has some facial scars some small facial scars some to the upper lip and
left eye her mental state on the report is listed as good her status is listed as runaway and it's noted that her
probable destination was 93 59 103rd Street Woodland Estates trailer park so she's missing she's reported missing by
mom mom catches a brief glimpse of her at some point but she's hearing from Neighbors as well that her daughter
still within the confines of this trailer park right there's so eyewitnesses that see her alive she's
just not going to school and just not coming home well it's tough we've all been 14 before and I know for me I
thought I knew everything and I thought I was smarter than my parents and I thought that I was Street wise and and
all those things back when I was 14. you quickly find out that you know little to
nothing that is so true that is absolutely true now as noted in the missing persons
report Angie believed Jennifer was still somewhere in the mobile home park and was just refusing to come home but later
on Monday evening Witnesses said that they saw Jennifer walking out of Woodland Estates on the access road to
the park this is a core according to Clay County Sheriff Scott Lancaster yet detectives found Witnesses who told them
that Jennifer was still hanging around the park staying with who knows and staying who knows where
until November 7th and it seems like this is the time that we really need to start calling everything into question
because right this is where she seems to have totally dropped off of the radar but here's one of the problems though
right you have this 14 year old girl roaming this park some of these Parks people will live there because the
background checks might be different I don't know if this park is similar to that or not
but you also have a situation where you have a condensed population and she's roaming this park not going to school
and she's basically advertising to any of the scumbags over there hey I'm not being supervised and I'm an easy target
I'm not going home my mother my parents don't know my exact whereabouts I'm not going to school so probably up to no
good during what's supposed to be school hours for her again this is really when
we start to call a lot of things into question this November 7th date and it seems like she drops off the radar
vanishes really at this point because this is where we lose track of Jennifer now this is going to take us
to November 8 2001. this is the Thursday after Jennifer was seen exiting the mobile
home park remember that was on Monday so three days earlier is when she was seen
but on this Thursday the 8th we have two teenage boys who decided that they were
going to go fishing this would be under a bridge now the Long Branch Creek runs through these kids Maxville neighborhood
in Clay County remember Jennifer was reported missing in Duval County right this area where these boys were
going to go fishing this is a remote area described as desolate in one article about 13 miles away from the
Woodland Estates and about two miles across the Clay County Duval County Line the boys slowly
worked their way down the creek embankment and got ready to bait their hooks when something in the water
stopped them in their tracks here's a quote from the Florida Times Union that reads quote they saw what they thought
was a body lying face down in the water sort of on her side with her hip up said
Mary Justino a spokeswoman for the Clay County Sheriff's Office they weren't sure if it was something left over from
a Halloween prank or a real body and as all of our garage regulars know we don't
cover Halloween pranks here on this show so unfortunately someday that's our new series we aspire
to cover Halloween pranks yeah and run again like we've learned in the last five years it's it's never a mannequin
so unfortunately a prank or a fake it was not on closer inspection the boys realized
that they had just discovered a body lying in the creek it was a naked female one of them ran to his nearby house and
told his father who then called The Clay County Sheriff's Office who responded to
the scene immediately the responding officers report was time stamped at 2100 hours this reports a body found at 609
County Road 217 Middleburg Florida it reflects the finding of a white female name and age
unknown incident type homicide suspect and weapon are both listed as UK for unknown the responding officer was
Sergeant CJ Jett who wrote the following statement on November 8 2001 at 15 30 hours so 3 30 hours I was notified via
departmently pager to respond to the area of 609 County Road 217 in reference to a death investigation the body of an
unidentified naked white female was found floating in the water next to a bridge I arrived at the scene at 1605
hours and observed the naked body of an unidentified white female with dark colored hair floating face down in the
water on the west side of County maintain two lane cement Bridge the victim's body was retrieved from the
water at 1805 hours the victim's body was later transported to the medical examiner's office in Jacksonville
Florida case pending one he got a fill for these two teenage boys that just were going fishing and find this body
and and at this point we don't know exactly what condition her body is in but we've seen some really terrible
cases where the bloating of the body and and water can make it a very horrific site and so this would be a pretty
traumatic experience for these teenage boys now you'll note that the incident report was found at 9 00 PM just a
handful of hours after the body was found this indicates that the body was the victim of a homicide so what we have
here is just by the officers arriving on scene they're visually able to determine
before even an autopsy takes place right that this we're talking about a homicide
here so how did Sergeant jet know this prior to an autopsy being performed the answer is simple it was obvious to
anyone who got a good look at the body I'm guessing puncture wounds well the the young female's body was riddled with
stab wounds her death had been extremely violent that's awful one article we found said her body was quote Savaged
detective Rob schoonover of the Clay County Sheriff's Office Cold Case division said to First Coast News quote
with the wounds that you could see during the autopsy it was very gruesome the way she died it was a horrible and
tragic death for her to have to go through [Music] [Music] [Applause] all right you filthy animals if you're
an animal and you're nasty make sure you check out our bonus show called off the
record on Stitch or premium you can find out more information at truecrime garage.com on that all right we're back
cheers to you Colonel cheers to you Captain cheers to all the people about the good seats up front the
officer responding to the creek where Jennifer's body was found was Sergeant jet who noted that the body was removed
and then sent to the Jacksonville medical examiner's office for the autopsy now we tried to get a copy of
this autopsy report but could not get our hands on it I have some speculation to offer up here in this regard though
just like most murder case investigations the physical evidence found at the scene along with the
details in that autopsy report might be the making or breaking point for your case but I believe here in Jennifer's
case it's even more important and that may become more clear as we continue on because as we get through some of these
details and specifics here Captain we are going to get into some rather interesting Suspects
in this case well a couple issues if you're dealing with this investigation is that the body is found in water so
water is known to get rid of certain parts of evidence also we don't know if her body was placed in the water and
then moved at some point the autopsy might be able to show us that but also being outdoors
it makes the the scene of the crime a lot larger and harder to search so that's a perfect setup for some of the
information that we are going to get into right here right now so I've been practicing that's right one statement we
were able to get our hands on does offer up some more info at least in regards to
the possible time of death Now that statement was officials said the unidentified woman died one to three
days before she was found plus Sheriff Lancaster told the media at the time that the body was mildly deteriorated
when it was found indicating that she had been dead for more than just a couple of hours now more recently
detective schoonover told us that Jennifer was seen alive the night before she was found so we know based off of
this information that she was dead for not more than about 24 hours right so we have a timeline and normally in these
investigations the more information we find the smaller that timeline becomes that's smaller
window of when the crime could have taken place now do they believe that she was murdered at sight or is this a
Dumping Ground because to me this seems like she was placed there after the murder so we also learned that she was
not bound or restrained in any way when she was found the Clay County Sheriff's Office spokeswoman Mary Justino told the
media that investigators believed that the woman found in the creek likely was killed at another location before her
body was dumped under a bridge on County Road 217 this road is just south of the Duval
County Line the bridge was a two-lane Highway over the creek now detective schoonover told True Crime
garage that investigators believe that the evidence at the scene showed that the woman had been thrown
off of the bridge and was already dead when she was discarded likely transported by vehicle so she was killed
somewhere else likely transported via motor vehicle and then thrown from the bridge rather than carried down the side
of the embankment and of course we know who the homicide victim was but at this time in our timeline for this story
who this young murder victim was was still unknown to investigators and the public on November 9th
the Clay County Sheriff's Office released some information about the woman found in Long Branch Creek
they were trying to gather information from the public about who she possibly was wanted to to your point like you
said she's found in a different County so one of the things that law enforcement is going to do is to reach
out to neighboring counties and go do you have a missing female yeah comparisons of her physical description
to that of missing persons reports from the area turned up nothing which is difficult because we know she
was reported missing but as you said this is a different County so again this is kind of surprising given the fact
that the person the missing persons report was filed in the adjacent County of Duval County
four days earlier but anyway they didn't put this together at the time so the Clay County officials issued a statement
and a facial reconstruction sketch of the unidentified victim the statement said that the body found was per the
Florida Times Union a white female in her early 20s who stands five foot two inches tall and weighs 115 pounds with
brown eyes and dark brown hair falling below her shoulders and she had a one and a half inch scar near her right eye
two scars on her right upper lip near her nose and a single piercing in both ears she was wearing a heart-shaped ring
and the weird thing here Captain is they they mentioned they kind of go out of their way when I you know trying to
describe this heart-shaped ring the interesting thing here Captain is when they describe that she's wearing this
heart-shaped ring they also say that she is wearing an engagement ring now obviously we've not seen photos from the
autopsy so we don't know if this is one and you know one in the same that the heart-shaped ring is an engagement ring
or that she was wearing two rings so I want to be clear about that before we move on it was then three days later on
November 12th that the Clay County Sheriff's Office was able to determine the identity of the homicide victim now
what happened was the Sheriff's Office officials ran the description of the victim we read earlier they ran this in
the Times Union newspaper on November 10th asking for the public to call in tips if they thought they knew who she
could be they also ran the sketch of the victim's face along with the article three days later
the Clay County Sheriff's Office spokesperson Mary Justino told the newspaper quote we got about 25 phone
calls based on the picture that had been put out of the 25 callers a few were people who thought it was this girl the
girl from the creek unfortunately was Jennifer menternack and after Jennifer's body was found we have a statement
issued by the family yes Jennifer's family had to be notified that their beloved daughters
was brutally killed Jennifer's mother must have felt a dis Jennifer's mother must have felt a
devastating combination of both guilt and effort my guess right over her argument with Jennifer that caused
Jennifer to leave but then the knowledge that she had gone above and beyond to trying to get Jennifer to come home
right by calling in a missing persons report before her daughter was even really missing missing now in an
impromptu news conference described by the Florida Times Union this took place on the mobile home park access road
Angie the mother declined to comment personally instead Jennifer's Uncle Matt Jackson read the family statement which
was basically asking anyone with any information about Jennifer slaying to come forward
now this was incredibly tragic for Angie because Angie had already lost a child at age one this before Jennifer was born
and then after that tragedy she then bravely decided to try to get pregnant again and did and the new baby was
Jennifer now Angie later told the Times Union in an interview about Jennifer quote I think children today are growing
up too fast I think she was too end quote Captain Ronnie Gann of the Clay County Sheriff's Office said to the
media quote this was a 14 year old girl who was brutally murdered and dumped in the creek like a piece of trash
now detectives were fully vested in this case from everything that I could find Captain all the articles that I was able
to review from 2001 my gut tells me these detectives were fully vested in this case and right from
Jump Street they were determined to get to the bottom of this thing and figure out who killed 14 year old Jennifer
medernick once the body was removed from the muddy water and hauled away to the medical examiner's office investigators
from the Clay County Sheriff's Office major case unit began combing the scene for Clues as to who the victim was and
who had killed her they scoured the creek Banks and Bridge area including nearby Woods until late on that Thursday
night and then reconvened for more of the same the next day on Friday divers were brought in to plumb the
depths of the Long Branch Creek to see what might have sunk to the bottom and although this was not revealed at the
time they did find something that is considered a crucial important piece of evidence remember we said that the
investigators believed that the body was thrown from the bridge Jennifer was already deceased at that time and that
she had been killed elsewhere well that's interesting considering what was found at the body recovery scene
recall that the police report from the responding Officer says that the body was floating in the water
the creek was about Waist Deep at its deepest parts but it was narrow and had Muddy Banks right it seems that Jennifer
was floating in a very shallow area of the creek and when medical examiner Personnel removed the body they found
something underneath of it none of this was released at the time detective schoonover revealed all of
this via a piece on First Coast News that ran back in 2018. it said underneath her body
investigators found the handle of a knife with strands of Jennifer's hair wrapped
around it they believe it was the murder weapon but the blade portion of the knife was never found
and as stated earlier the knife handle was just one of several pieces of evidence collected from the scene vom
law enforcement I'm bringing out a scent dog I know that the thought is that she
disappeared from one County she's found in this County but maybe a scent dog will
lead us in some direction of where this vehicle or this person would have went after they dumped Jennifer's Body
the other thing I'm doing is I'm going back to the park and having cadaver dogs walk around
every trailer because again they believe that the murder scene was somewhere else
and not at the creek yeah and we know that she was seen at different points in that trailer park so that seems to me
like probably the most likely place if something did go down that led to her death it may have occurred there
now investigators believe that the brass screw top knife handle that was found which as the news piece said has
Jennifer's Hair entwined in it was a part of the murder weapon the thinking is that at some point the blade broke
off the blade portion of the knife Captain has never been found it was not found in
Jennifer's Body and the creek was searched thoroughly more than once detective schoonover believes that the
knife which was a unique Style with a very large blade broke during the commission of the murder during the
stabbing of Jennifer for some reason her killer threw the handle into the water where it lay on
the muddy creek bottom under her body again the blade however is never accounted for this is a weird portion of
the case to me right it seems to me like I get it you got to get rid of this body
and you probably want to get rid of the murder weapon as well but you've only managed to get rid of a portion of the
murder weapon so I kind of kept going around and playing around with this in my head over
and over again is this something that's just happenstance that uh something that
was unlucky to the killer that the the knife handle ended up in the creek with Jennifer or was this something that
was done on purpose the knife itself as described as the detective as unique the best way for me
to describe it and there are some pictures of this knife handle that are available online this is one of those
cases though captain that you're not going to find a whole lot of information about online it's one of the
it's kind of a lesser-known Florida case but the knife handle itself to kind of give a little perspective on
why we have the handle but not the blade what it looks like to me is that the blade portion probably screwed on top of
the handle or the guard to the handle you'll see these knives a lot they're like survival type knives where the
handle itself is Hollow because in the hollow handle they usually you can screw off the bottom and
place things inside of the handle right A lot of people for survival type knives
will place things like matches or what have you inside of the handle cocaine what this makes is for a
a situation where the the blade or the there's a technical term for it and I'm probably going to get 12 emails about it
but the the blade itself does not go fully down into the handle so it makes it more easily to break off right
and what you see here in the pictures is you can see hair around the top of the the handle
as well as what looks to be well I'm sorry not just looks to be but it's labeled as victim's Blood on the handle
itself but where she was roaming when she left her mother's trailer in the trailer park
there was some shady stuff going on in this park yeah so let's talk about these Woodland Estates for a bit because it
seems to be that once she as you said Captain left her mom's home she's then known to have been moving around staying
God knows where right but we have a lot of statements eyewitness statements of people who saw her people who talked
with her in the days leading up to her death and they're all saying hey she was still
here in the Woodland Estate so as it turns out more like hoodlum Estates the police were all too familiar with the
mobile home park where the metternacks lived here's a quote from a resident named Cindy Bose who lived near the
meternix she did not know them personally but her daughter was one of the witnesses who
said that they saw Jennifer walking away from the direction of her home on Monday
afternoon Cindy told the Times Union quote this place is messed up there's a lot of
fighting and drugs the police are here all of the time of course investigators conducted interviews with residents of
the mobile home park they could not talk to everyone based on the sheer size of the place but they
canvassed the neighborhood and spoke with teens loitering in the area and anyone who answered the door when they
knocked to ask questions they were hoping that the teens in the neighborhood might know Jennifer right
might have known her personally or maybe help them fill out their timeline a little bit leading up to her murder now
several of them did know Jennifer and per the Times Union said that several teens said that they had known the teen
they described Jennifer as a quiet girl without particular friends or vices saying quote she didn't mess with nobody
she just kept to herself said Steven Smalls he goes on to say that she was the kind of person that trusted anybody
through their canvas police found that this trusting naive nature might have made Jennifer vulnerable
and as you pointed out earlier Captain if she's out telling people I'm Outdoors I'm not staying at my mom's
house that too makes her vulnerable as well detective Rob schoonover of the Clay
County Sheriff's Office who reopened this case in 2018 and who spoke with us told the First Coast News that Jennifer
had gotten involved in the adult party scene at Woodland Estates per the news report quote in the days leading up to
her death detective schoonover says some of the adult men in the mobile home park
were seen hanging around her and she was spotted at a party he goes on to say that there were parties going on where
she was present with illegal drugs again this from detective schoonover the other issue too is if she's staying with
a friend one night if her friend's parents say Hey you know you need to go back home you can't stay
here so now you have this 14 year old kid with not that many options so even if somebody that you don't know too well
and adult says hey well you can stay here with me you might take that option because it's
your only option I agree I I think what we're looking at here Captain is a situation where Jennifer was
couch surfing and she may have been staying with people that are not so readily willing to admit that she crashed at
their place right for a night or two yeah because they just don't want to be even looked at as a suspect yeah or
they're adult men right right you don't want to be no creepos yeah you don't want law
enforcement knowing that you're hanging out with a juvenile and that she's seen at locations that contain illegal drugs
the other thing that needs to happen in this case is like you said she's a 14 year old girl
we need to do the old pervert Roundup well that was something that was absolutely conducted now what we do know
per law enforcement is that Jennifer was hanging out with adult men and we have to factor in
the fact that based off of the information we have from the body recovery scene was that Jennifer was wearing what some
have said look to be like an engagement ring so the other thing that I want to know is who gave her
that ring who gave that ring to her right was this someone who wanted her to feel
emotionally invested in trusting was this the you know made to look like some type of
relationship between unknown person and 14 year old Jennifer yeah or she's couch surfing as a item
that she stole from somebody could be but until you have an explanation for why that item is found on her body you
have to seek out that explanation a few days after Jennifer was identified Clay County Sheriff Scott Lancaster asked the
public to call police if they had any idea where Jennifer was during that time frame and who she had been with in the
time period of November 5th to November 8th when she was eventually found he said that the investigation was a
joint effort between clay and Duval County authorities and somewhat disheartingly Sheriff
Lancaster said that there were no suspects in Jennifer's murder but this is not or was not
really true or if it was true it would not be for long yeah but sometimes law enforcement Miss speaks and maybe it was
just we have no suspects at this time that we're willing to tell the public about correct and it looks to me that at
some point detectives made up their minds pretty much about who had killed Jennifer
and we've seen this in several other cases the problem was proving it so no arrests were made immediately
after finding her body or having her identified no arrests were made in their initial efforts in the investigation so
the case stalled [Music] [Applause] [Music] for everything True Crime Check out true
crime garage.com and join us back here tomorrow for part two that's right don't do anything don't go anywhere stay right
there part two is coming at you tomorrow here in the garage until then be good be
kind and don't live foreign [Music]

Jennifer Medernach /// Part 1 /// 532

Part 1 of 2 www.TrueCrimeGarage.com

This week in the Garage we review the still unsolved homicide of Jennifer Medernach. It has now been twenty years since the day that Jennifer’s mother reported her missing. 14 year old Jennifer Medernach left after an argument with her mother. She was spotted several times over the course of the next few days, still in the families’ neighborhood. But the story turned to tragedy when her body was found in a creek several days after being reported missing. This case is still very active and getting some justice for Jennifer is still very likely. Anyone with information should reach out to the Clay County Sheriff’s Office @ 904-264-6512.

Beer of the Week - Hazy Jane New England IPA by BrewDog Garage Grade - 4 and a quarter bottle caps out of 5 Our show - True Crime Garage “Off the Record” is available only on Stitcher Premium. For a FREE month of listening go to http://stitcherpremium.com/truecrimegarage and use promo code GARAGE

Beer Fund: https://truecrimegarage.com/home

Brief Summary

The episode details the murder of 14-year-old Jennifer Metternack and the investigation into her disappearance and death.

Key points

The Disappearance of Jennifer Medernick. A 14-year-old girl goes missing, leading to a tragic discovery days later.
The Missing Persons Report. Jennifer's mother reports her daughter missing after days of absence.
Body Found in the Creek. Teenage boys discover a body while fishing, leading to a homicide investigation.
Gruesome Discovery. The body found in the creek shows signs of a violent death.
Discovery of the Body. The body of Jennifer was found, indicating she had been dead for over 24 hours.
Investigation Insights. Detectives believe Jennifer was murdered elsewhere and dumped in the creek.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

Some evil monster simply discarded her like trash.

Describing the brutal nature of the crime.

4:15WatchNov 2, 2022

Tension

75/ 100High tension

More from True Crime Garage TV

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.