Henthorn jurors on reaching a verdict | Forensic Files

so you go back to deliberate you enter that room you all take a seat or you stand around for what happens as you
walk in that room we went back in and I think we took a moment to just reflect on everything cuz we had heard so much
testimony and we had so much evidence we wanted to make sure that we looked at the evidence that they presented to us
to make sure we hadn't missed anything or misinterpreted something it was important for every person on that jury
to leave that room with unanimous decision that everybody felt good about at the end of the day and if anyone had
any doubt in their mind we needed to hear it we needed to hear it then because we wanted everyone to be able to
live with the decisions we made there was one juror that uh was undecided for a long period of time and she kept
saying I need time for my notes to read my notes and we gave her that time she stood her ground she looked at the
evidence and she helped us to reexamine a few times so by the time we made a decision it was one that we were all
very confident with our po person said who's for guilty and every hand in the room went up every hand every hand when
the judge read that guilty verdict and I heard somebody cheer I I wanted to cheer
right with them because I I could feel how happy they were and I just couldn't imagine what they went through so I
always like to ask a JY you guys can sleep well at night oh yes proud proud of this verdict yes pretty much so

On Sept. 21, 2015, a jury found Harold Henthorn guilty of the 2012 murder of his second wife, Toni, by pushing her off a cliff to her death in Rocky Mountain National Park. Four jurors --Jerry Taboada, Dawn Roberts, Marxy Miller-Zahn, and Christine Vogel -- spoke with "48 Hours"' Peter Van Sant about their 10-hour deliberation.

Brief Summary

Jurors discuss their deliberation process and the emotional impact of reaching a unanimous guilty verdict.

Key points

Unanimous Decision. The jury reflects deeply before reaching a unanimous verdict, ensuring everyone feels good about it.
A Juror's Doubt. One juror takes her time to review the evidence, impacting the final decision.
Emotional Verdict. The moment of the guilty verdict brings overwhelming emotions to the jury.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

We needed to hear it then.

Emphasizing the importance of every juror's voice.

0:39WatchNov 22, 2015

More from 48 Hours

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.