Harold Henthorn's former girlfriend speaks out | Forensic Files

I fell in love with Harold henthorne because he was a handsome charismatic very affectionate kind individual and he was
just what I was looking for and I just saw a really beautiful future with Harold hunor and he loved my kids wanted
to marry him I knew he was a widower but he didn't really go into details so uh he told me initially his wife was killed
in an auto accident and that he loved her very much and I was like I didn't really talk
about it when he said auto accident are you thinking like a collision yes I I I thought she was killed in a
horrible Collision he said it happened at night and I was just like oh that's so horrible and then in another
conversation he said I really feel guilty about her death because I was in the car when she died she was driving
and I was sleeping when Harold was getting to know you did he ask you about your financial situation I had a very
big house that I got out of my divorce and I had equity in it and I lived in a very substantial neighborhood I mean was
it did make you even more attractive to him possibly cuz he came back honestly today do you think he left you because
maybe you weren't worth enough for him maybe he didn't see you as uh having great cash potential for him I
absolutely believe that after everything I've read Because I presented very well
on that big house at the Estates of 6th Avenue and all of the Exotic things that
I still had in the home from my divorce I believe Harold would have potentially married me

Henthorn's two wives, Lynn and Toni, died under suspicious circumstances 17 years apart. After Henthorn's first wife died, Toni Taylor says she briefly dated Henthorn in 1999, and shares details of their relationship with "48 Hours"' Peter Van Sant.

Brief Summary

A woman reflects on her relationship with Harold Henthorne, questioning his motives and the impact of her financial status.

Key points

Falling in Love. She fell for Harold Henthorne, a handsome and affectionate man.
The Tragic Past. Harold's wife died in an auto accident, which he feels guilty about.
Financial Concerns. Questions arise about whether financial status influenced Harold's intentions.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

I fell in love with Harold Henthorne.

WatchNov 22, 2015

More from 48 Hours

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.