While She Was Sleeping
- Jan 28, 2021
- 1:23:10
- Full Episode
In this Dateline classic, the snow covered playground of Aspen, Colorado is a safe haven for well-heeled owners and celebrities. That is until one cold February night when a frantic woman calls 9-1-1 about a discovery at a secluded chalet. Keith Morrison reports. Originally aired on NBC on October 10, 2014.
Keith Morrison speaks with Det. Miller, now retired, about the case that still perplexes her 10 years later and digs into the investigator’s 30-year career.
After the Verdict is available now only by subscription to Dateline Premium: https://apple.co/4c877zC
Learn about the cases of unsolved missing and murdered Indigenous people Dateline has covered: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/in-the-news/missing-murdered-indigenous-people-featured-dateline-nbcs-missing-amer-rcna142027
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Brief Summary
Nancy Pfister was murdered in Aspen, leading to a complex investigation and shocking confessions from her former tenants.
Key points
- Nancy Pfister's Life. Nancy Pfister was a beloved figure in Aspen, known for her vibrant personality.
- The Discovery. The shocking discovery of Nancy's body in her own home sends ripples through Aspen.
- More Than One Suspect. The investigation reveals that moving Nancy's body required more than one person.
- A Fresh Start Turns Sour. The Stylers hoped for a new beginning in Aspen, but their relationship with Nancy Pfister soured quickly.
- The Discovery of Evidence. A city worker finds a bloody hammer and a prescription bottle belonging to Nancy Pfister, linking the Stylers to the crime.
- Arresting Developments. Just days after Nancy Pfister's body is found, the Stylers are arrested for her murder.
Episode highlights
- Nancy Pfister's LifeNancy Pfister was a beloved figure in Aspen, known for her vibrant personality.“You cannot come to this town without meeting Nancy.”3:10Jan 28, 2021
- The DiscoveryThe shocking discovery of Nancy's body in her own home sends ripples through Aspen.“When I opened that door, that odor is so overwhelming.”14:21Jan 28, 2021
- More Than One SuspectThe investigation reveals that moving Nancy's body required more than one person.“It is awkward and difficult to move a body.”22:09Jan 28, 2021
- A Fresh Start Turns SourThe Stylers hoped for a new beginning in Aspen, but their relationship with Nancy Pfister soured quickly.“But it wasn't long before the stylers discovered that living with Nancy Pfister was not quite like they thought it might be.”26:13Jan 28, 2021
- The Discovery of EvidenceA city worker finds a bloody hammer and a prescription bottle belonging to Nancy Pfister, linking the Stylers to the crime.“When he opened the bag, he looks inside and he sees a prescription pill bottle.”38:01Jan 28, 2021
- Arresting DevelopmentsJust days after Nancy Pfister's body is found, the Stylers are arrested for her murder.“They knocked on the door. I stepped out of the door and they said, we're arresting you for murder one.”40:40Jan 28, 2021
- Doubts About the CaseQuestions arise about the evidence against the Stylers and the possibility of a setup.“It looked like a setup to you.”42:10Jan 28, 2021
- The Investigation IntensifiesKathy Carpenter is subjected to extensive questioning, raising suspicions about her involvement.“Five days, almost 20 hours of questioning.”54:22Jan 28, 2021
