Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 8, Episode 2 | Forensic Files

[Music] next on Unsolved Mysteries in the ashes of a garage fire police find a body of Clarence rockets
and then 10 years later another fire kills his wife and the body of Clarence Roberts is found again how can one man
die twice few people know that Elvis Presley had a twin brother who died at Birth
some believe that the tragic loss inspired Elvis to greatest the heartbreaking death of a
six-year-old girl remains a mystery that her family and friends still want to solve and police and California need
your help to track down a doctor who sexually assaulted his trusting patients murder missing persons wanted
fugitives and the parent normal I'm Dennis finina and this is Unsolved Mysteries
[Music] [Music] in Nashville Indiana two of the most respected residents were Clarence and
Geneva Roberts that is until they became the center of a local controversy a tangled mystery of lies
and deception one winter night a fire raged out of control behind the Robert's home
when the ashes cooled firefighters discovered a body it was soon identified as Clarence Roberts 10 years later there
was another fire two more bodies were discovered the first was Geneva Roberts the second was none other than Clarence
Roberts how could the same man die twice it was just one more question about the
mysterious Clarence Roberts I talked to both detectives that was on the second fire and from what they told me I'd say
it was definitely Clarence I still think Clarence died in the first far I don't think Clarence Roberts died in the
second far I I just don't believe that I think Clarence is still alive I sure do people in Nashville are still
wondering about Clarence Roberts he was a businessman a former sheriff and a board member of of the local bank it was
hard to imagine anyone more successful and yet somewhere along the way a different side of Clarence Roberts began
to emerge before his troubles began Clarence owned the thriving hardware store with his brother Carson he and I
worked together for about 22 years Clarence always seemed to be pretty happy he enjoyed working Clarence was
outgoing he was friendly and always made friends with people and always got along
with people what Clarence and his wife Geneva had been married 20 years Geneva came from a
poor family but together she and Clarence made a good life for themselves then Clarence began spending
money more money than he had he purchased three luxury cars and a home he could not
afford to finance his extravagant lifestyle Clarence sold the hardware store and put everything he had into
real estate Investments those Ventures failed and Clarence found himself in serious financial trouble for all the
money that he was losing everything going down the drain he was going for a millionaire or broke and he was ending
up broke he was trying to pull out of it finally even Clarence and Geneva's cars were repossessed
they were deeply in debt with nowhere to turn he wasn't the clearance that I had
always been used to being around he was down he was really depressed and I feel that he was
suicidal and then the fire one month after the Robert's cars were taken firefighters arrived to discover the
garage of their home engulfed in flames there the heat was so intense that they can only stand by helplessly while the
structure burned to the ground once the fire had cooled they made a gruesome Discovery Chief come
back here I think we got a body a body in the ashes was burned beyond recognition a half melted Shotgun by its
side the coroner feared that Clarence had finally escaped his deaths by taking his
own we thought it shot himself there wasn't much doubt in our mind that he just got too many warriors ahead of him
and he' committed suicide so when we got back down to the funeral home we started
looking for shots and U we couldn't find any questions began to surface the coroner wondered how Clarence could have
taken his own life without firing a single shot when detective Don kuster carefully sifted through the ashes he
found a ring that had belonged to Clarence despite the intense heat the ring was not
damaged there's no way that ring could have withstood the heat of that far like it did and not even have a damage port
on it at all I definitely think the ring was a plant uh it just it had to be it was the
first of many Clues suggesting the fire was not what it seemed police learned that a few months before the fire
Clarence had taken out several life insurance policies totaling close to a million do a test of the body found in
the ashes showed type AB blood Clarence had type B blood if it wasn't the body of Clarence Roberts then who was it
eyewitnesses provide a possible answer just 2 days before the blaze Clarence had been spotted in a bar
buying drinks for a homeless man according to the eyewitnesses as he and Clarence were leaving the bar The
Drifter passed out and collapsed Clarence said he'd take him to the hospital and Clarence left with him and
later on I checked the hospitals within a 300 mile radius and this man was not admitted to a hospital
anymore now there were two theories about Clarence one scenario was that he had killed himself
the other that Clarence Roberts had murdered the transient then staged his own fiery death in order to collect the
insurance money suicidal yes that to commit murder no way I can't believe he could have been any part of that it
would be hard be beyond my wildest imagination to think that Clarence robers could ever been involved with
anything like that definitely definitely he was capable of [Music] it Clarence was either dead or missing
and Geneva was definitely alone with no money and no Clarance she was forced to move back to the wrong side of the
tracks her claims to the insurance money were denied the financial setbacks took their
toll on Geneva she avoided her friends and neighbors eventually becoming the target of local gossip shopkeepers said
that Geneva began buying a lot of beer that was surprising as she was a diabetic and almost never drank beer
reports began to surface that someone else was hanging around Geneva's house we had developed information that
a man had been seen behind Geneva's residence the man acted very strangely he would never let anyone get close to
him and he always seemed to duck away from them and head back toward the house immediately I'm sure that was probably
Clarence I think he had perhaps run out of places to go you know and he had come
back uh to staying with Geneva he was the mysterious man that was seen behind her house Geneva was able to keep the
identity of the mysterious man a secret at least until the night of the second fire
[Music] when my office called and explained that it was Geneva's house on fire and that they thought Geneva was
still inside the house I went right to the fire scene and the fire was still burning very intensely at that
time after the fire was extinguished why we just stayed behind and I'm not even sure why um I just just wanted to look
further sifting through the ashes Searchers found the charred body of Geneva Roberts hours later they made
another startling Discovery Geneva's body had been removed to the funeral home and the fire had been extinguished
the house was totally demolished so we'd gone through the reubel and a fireman had located a
second body in another part of the house and I was just so certain that it would
be that of Clarence I recognized him immediately by his chest x-ray now I knew that I was going to
have a difficult time to tell uh all of my friends and Neighbors in the world that Clarence was dead for
the second time it just um turned out to be Clarence and I I was very pleased with that uh that this
might be coming to an end little did I know that it was just starting it looks like someone just came
in the back door and poured all the way around the walls the second fire was a clear cut case of arson we could follow
very clearly these burn patterns from Geneva's bed into the adjacent room where clarence's body was located
and then down a hallway and out the back door of that house so we determined right there that
at least Geneva had been murdered we're sure that turpentine was used to ignite this
fire we know that we simply don't know who started it whether it was clearance that started
the fire or that of a third party I subscribe to the the theory of a third party police have no clue as to who set
the second fire but they believe they have identified the second victim so I'm absolutely convinced that the second
victim the victim in the second fire is that of Clarence Roberts there's just no
doubt in my mind there's not a doubt in my mind at all I'm absolutely convinced that Clarence Roberts died in the second
fire and that some person possibly a derel uh died in in the first fire and when I say absolutely I mean that this
is uh not only a reasonable medical certainty uh but we beyond a shadow of a doubt the mystery of Clarence Roberts
lies buried in this small Cemetery in Nashville Indiana but the questions remain who was the man in the first fire
who set the second fire and why and and the key questions where is Clarence Roberts and is he even buried in his own
grave police believe that there is someone who knows the truth about Clarence and Geneva Roberts if you have
any information about this case please log on to our website at unsolved.com next few people know that Alvis Presley
had a twin brother who died at Birth some believe that his twin inspired his legendary
[Music] F Memphis Tennessee Elvis Presley the king of rock and roll his life story is a classic a
shy teenager from the wrong side of town becomes a superstar but what few people
know about Elvis is that he was haunted his entire life by the death of his twin
brother Jesse [Music] Garen Elvis was born in this Shack in East Tupelo Mississippi records show
that his twin brother was born first more than a half hour before Elvis but by the time Elvis was born Jesse Garen
Presley had already been declared dead Jesse was buried in an unmarked grave in this nearby Cemetery
today many believe his death had profound emotional consequences for Elvis some say that it was the driving
force behind both his creative genius and his self-destruction when Elvis was a child
5 6 years old he used to tell me that he used to hear a voice inside of his head
and he used to confuse him and he used to scare him a little bit and he was afraid to mention it to anyone he
thought perhaps it was his brother Jesse communicating to him telling him what to
do music was Elvis's way of communicating with Jesse the two had been bonded before they were born inter
utterly with the Rhythm and the voice of the fundamentalist Assembly of God Church a very important Cornerstone for
understanding Elin Dr Peter Whitmer has devoted years to studying the psychology of twins
especially those who have been separated by Death the surviving child is often referred to as a twinless
twin many twinless twins including Elvis tend to become should we say superstitious Elvis would look to his
twin for signs of guidance for signs of strength Elvis also felt that Jesse was his Compass was a sign of direction that
Elvis should in fact do great things that had the two of them been United they would have been able to do great
things that they were separated Elvis alone had to be the Creator the perfectionist there are more than a half
a million twinless twins in the world today like Elvis Presley they're United by a common but unusual Bond a strange
belief that the spirit of the dead twin lives on I do feel the presence of someone else in my life I've um again I
it's only been recently that I've thought thought to put it in that framework of the twin I've thought of it
more as a guardian angel or a or a spiritual presence for some of Dr Raymond brand coined the term twinless
twin and founded a nationwide support group for them twins are unique because there's one thing that a twin a multiple
has that single birth people do not and that's called unal bonding of course today with ultrasounds and
studying behavor in uteral and we realize that they hug and what appears to be kissing and even
perhaps slugging or pushing at each other we understand and accept today that uteral bonding begins at the moment
of conception consider the case of Dean sites born an identical twin Deanne became twinless when her sister Shannon
died just 5 hours after birth she may have died 22 years ago but I can feel her presence all the time Shannon's my
guardian angel she watches over me you know she kind of makes sure nothing really bad happens to me or my
family the aunt says that while she was on her way to work she had a dramatic psychic experience with her lost twin
theanne believes her sister saved her life it was about 9:00 in the morning and I was going down the offramp
and this feeling came over me I could feel Shannon's presence really strong next to me and then almost like her
presence came over me and had me pull over to the right and then stop and then not even 5 seconds
later Shan was telling me to pull over before I got hit it wasn't as if she said you know
hello I'm here it's just the feeling the security of her being around because my twin died in the womb I lived
and she died there's a sense that I've carried with me forever that somehow I took too much for example I must have
eaten all the food or uh you know I was the one who lived and uh I carried a a deep sense of guilt about being here not
until we find that's the downside the guilt another many people believe it is guilt that drives twinless twins to
Great Heights or the depth of self-destruction some say the root cause of Elvis Presley's emotional
torment was his sadness and feeling of responsibility for his twin brother's death Elvis's friend Larry Geller
recalls a conversation that took place a year before Elvis died he said man I had
a dream the other night I can't get it out of my head I got to tell you there I was with my twin brother
Jesse he had the same hairstyle The Sideburns the same eyes one Spotlight on him one Spotlight on
me but Larry the strangest thing I started to feel guilty I I felt like like I did
something wrong and I don't know why it's the weirdest feeling and I I said well maybe it's kind of simple you lived
and he didn't Elvis never was able to resolve his psychological HST over the death of
Jesse it was something that was at the core of all of his behavior from my perspective his substance abuse his
self-abuse in general his working himself to death was the desire to reunite with
Jesse I remember one time we were talking and he was telling me about his mother he used to question her about his
twin brother Jesse Garen and she said to him Elvis God took your twin brother back home to heaven
and someday we'll all be together again and Ela said to me Lawrence I believe that we're all going
home someday I'm going to be with my twin brother [Music] again for now medical science cannot
explain the psychic connections of twinless twins and though some might think they lead troubled lives the twins
themselves believe that they have been gifted [Music] next the search for a young woman who
disappeared near a lake in Alabama Lake Guntersville Alabama early morning wond Betty Dorman tries to wake
up her 26-year-old niece Wanda Jean maize Wanda Wanda but Wanda doesn't answer Betty calls her grandson John for help
get out of the way Wanda Wanda's Uncle ran down to the lake and saw a piece of clothing on the
duck it was Wanda torn and bloody night gown his first thought was that Wanda had fallen into the water and
[Music] drowned the Alabama State Rescue Squad began dragging the lake searching for
clues or a body they found nothing Wanda's parents couldn't do anything but wait I never fought for a
minute Wanda was in the water Wanda is an excellent swimmer and a Survivor she's always been a
Survivor within a few hours the rescue squad found an abandoned canoe and towed it to shore inside were traces of
blood after seeing the the blood in the boat I knew that she was alone and hurt and needed medical attention the thing
that you feel inside when you have the possibility of losing a daughter is Indescribable I never be the
same until I know what happened to one homicide investigators were called in detective Ed teal took charge of the
investigation when we arrived We examined the canoe blood samples taken from that all this Blood was sent to the
lab and came back to being her type of blood like a little blood stain in this canoe this is the most mysterious case
that I've ever worked I've never worked a case in 10 years where someone just vanished when I came into the room I
noticed that the bed the cover had been turned back but no one had never slept in the bed appearance of what was
identified as her clothing was lying in a chair her purse her identification checkbooks Rings watch everything was
laying on the the nightstand I got to looking at the wall here the glass that was broke
out there are two panes of glass that was broken the thing that baffles me the most about this is that no one in the
house heard the breaking of the glass or the beating of the venician blinds that's a lot of
Racket more than a few questions remain unanswered how could Wanda's aunt and uncle have slept through the sound of
the window being broken if Wanda was the victim of Foul Play Why was the bedroom
window broken from the inside why would Wanda take off her night gown and leave it on the dock and why were there blood
stains in the canoe there were no answers and Wanda Jean ma herself seemed to have vanished into the Alabama
night update 18 years after Wanda disappeared the remains of a body were discovered in
a remote area 2 mi from the lake we're sad to say they were Wanda jeans however there were no signs of Foul Play and
police now believe that Wanda was disoriented by the darkness and fell to her death in the Rocky terrain the case
is now closed next a 6-year-old girl is found dead less than a block from her house
what happened to Catherine corzilius [Music] Boston Texas at the age of six Katherine
corzilius seemed to be leading a Charmed Life she lived in a good neighborhood with her loving parents Nancy and Paul
and her brother Chris her father was personal manager for Rockstar John bonjovi when Catherine played her first
piano recital no one imagined that she would never live to see the first grade her untimely death would be memorialized
by family friend John [Music] Banji August 7th 4:15 that's when Nancy and Paul's world
came crashing down it was Paul's birthday he was working at his office in New York City
Nancy and the kids had spent the day running errands around Austin picking out gifts for
him it uh was very quiet here in our neighborhood as it usually is in fact I I can remark that it it was
exceptionally quiet that day on the way home they stopped to pick up the mail it was a ritual Catherine
looked forward [Music] to Nancy knew what would happen next mommy may I want come sure I'll see you
when you get there okay it was Catherine's way of saying that she was a big girl I allowed Catherine to do that
because I knew she was ready to be more independent and she had done it before Nancy and Chris drove home one way while
Catherine walked home in the opposite direction the shorter way home the corzilius family lives here on elders
Circle the community mailboxes are located here Nancy and Chris drove home in this direction Catherine apparently
followed this route both of my children had walked home together and separately from the
mailboxes it's a short walk probably less than a quar of a mile when Chris and I got home we
unloaded our car and started putting our packages away mom what Catherine's not back she tried to stop somewhere along
the way go back up on the road see if you can find her all right he came back in just a very short
period of time a few minutes and he was crying and he said she's not there Mom we got in the car and drove right next
door to our neighbors I ran down the steps to their front door knocked on the door their son answered
[Applause] hi is Catherine here no ma'am she hasn't been by here at all I believe uh at that moment Chris
and I knew that something terrible had happened minutes later Nancy would find out just how
terrible I could take fell that she was unconscious but she was breathing and I knew it was too hot to leave her on the
pavement I know that it's never a good idea to move somebody if you don't know what their injuries are but I just
couldn't leave her there and I think having driven her to the emergency before knowing the way very well I felt
confident that I was able to to drive that drive Catherine suffered a fractured skull she never regained the conscious
Catherine was on a ventilator to keep her breathing but she was brain dead it wasn't a matter of her being in a coma
or being unconscious uh her brain had died I arranged for a charter aircraft so that
could come directly home but in the end it was too late anyway I arrived at 12:30 in the morning and I believe she
was pronounced dead at 11:30 that night hour before my arrival from the start everyone just
assumed that Catherine had been the victim of a hit and run driver however as police searched for the suspect other
disturbing theories began to surface Catherine left her mother's car here and head it in this direction less than 10
minutes later she was found here on the opposite side of the circle half a mile away the medical examiner's report only
deepened the mystery he determined that Catherine had not died from a hit-and run accident dangerous that Catherine
sustain could have been the result of either uh jumping from a moving vehicle uh being thrown from a moving vehicle or
falling from a moving vehicle the type of injuries that we expect expect in these circumstances would have been the
same if Catherine did Tumble from a moving vehicle whose vehicle was it and was she pushed or did she fall one of
the theories that investigators proposed was that indeed somehow Catherine had jumped on the back of our vehicle
without nany's knowledge and uh as the vehicle drove around ear Circle she had fallen off which was uh a way to explain
where she was found in El Circle which is completely opposite of where she would have been on her normal
route the corzilius family was stunned was it possible that Nancy was respons responsible for her daughter's death
Paul and Nancy hired their own private investigator Barbara O'Brien she found the scenario hard to believe Hot August
day this whole car would have been very very hot there's only one place to hold on to all the way up here and the door
is the only other place down here to hold on to and it opens when you get a hold of it she also had a broken left
thumb and she had a splin on her thumb so it would have been extremely difficult for her to get a hold on
anything and her mother would have seen her in the rear view mirror the corzilius family has their
own Theory they believe their daughter was abducted and murdered a search of a vacant overgrown lot just 30 yard from
the mailboxes may have provided a crucial clue a few days after Catherine's uh death the investigators
did bring in the can9 unit and search the area they did pick up her scent over in this vacant lot which would indicate
that she was coming in this direction from the mailboxes taking the most direct route
home the scent was lost however which tells us that this may have been the point where she was abducted or the
injury took place but she was then later moved where she was found by her mother
she looked like she'd been laid out there for me to find her hair was smooth down her shirt was straight her shorts
were straight her toes were pointed straight her sandals were on I know someone moved her and I know someone
laid her there for me to find after all the investigations and speculation the cause of Catherine's
death remains a mystery in the quiet neighborhood on Elder Circle her memory lives on
Catherine's neighbors have planted a tree and placed a plaque in her name I think if Paul and Nancy's parents
knew how it happened perhaps it could help them with the closure of this tragic event nothing that anyone can say
or do is ever going to bring their daughter back to him but it's twice as hard not knowing what
happened I think of uh families of people who are missing an action well they're not here but what
happened to them and that's exactly to a certain extent how I feel about our daughter I had Catherine's body but
something happened in the last 15 minutes of her life then I I don't know what that
was the investigation in the Catherine's death has ground to a halt if you have any information that might help resolve
this case please log on to our website at unsolved.com next a family doctor is on the Run
charged with the brutal rape of a patient San Diego California hi we will call this young
woman Patricia when she was 19 years old Patricia went to a clinic complaining of
flu symptoms you know what if you just take a seat it'll just be a few minutes Patricia had no way of knowing that the
doctor who was about to see her had recently been forced to resign from another clinic four different complaints
of sexual misconduct had been filed against them each by a young woman in her 20s the doctor's name was Arvin son the
California State Medical Board ruled that son could keep his license because there were no witnesses to the assaults
it was the patient word against the doctors Dr shha right now shha hi he kep asking me questions about family about
um having a boyfriend and I was really sick I had a fever I wasn't feeling well this combined with um all the
questioning it really just threw me off you know I just figured that he was just
trying to be more help F and caring Patricia says that once the nurse left Dr son's examination quickly became
a sexual assault he manipulated me into a position where I couldn't even see what he was
doing and I didn't even know what he was doing or trying to do until I'd finally
realized that he had raped me after he had left the room I just started crying I knew what had happened but I just
could not believe that that had happened to me I'm okay Patricia was afraid to let
anyone at the clinic know what happened a short time later Patricia's parents took her to another hospital and local
police were notified after a week-long investigation Arvin was arrested he had no reaction he kept
repeating after I told him what she was alleging he said oh how interesting and throughout the interview he repeated how
interesting no emotion no reaction just uh he said he didn't do it that he might
have been frame but uh I would have expected a little reaction out of an innocent
person the next day Arvin posted $175,000 bail within a month he had disappeared later his medical license
was revoked by the state of California Every Woman he's around is in danger he's not going to
stop he had four warnings and lost a job and then he came back and raped Patricia
he's not going to stop the only two places I really felt safe was at church or at the doctor's
office you know and now you know I don't have that trust for anybody anywhere Arvin Sona is 5' 6 in tall with
dark hair and dark eyes he graduated from medical school in his native India and completed his residency in Dayton
Ohio authorities believe that Arvin sinhal is still working in the medical profession somewhere in the United
States possibly in a small town he is wanted on 13 counts of rape and three counts of sexual battery if you have any
information that could help lead to his arrest please log on to our website at unsolved.com
Daytona Florida teenagers have a reputation for being moody but by all accounts the case
of 19-year-old Tim molner was extreme without warning Tim simply drove away from home one day and out of his
family's life Tim was a rather quiet uh sensitive type of a person but he was always very
polite and well-mannered and he was doing well in school was on the dean list in fact and uh he was a very
likable person on the day Tim left his parents grew more and more frightened with each
passing hour his 14-year-old brother Frank had been the last family member to see Tim said to have a nice day there's
a pretty good age difference between us but we still hung out a lot cuz you know
we got along real good and pretty open relationship and um I could just tell something was something was bothering
him why it wasn't really saying seemed like there was a lot going on in his mind two weeks passed with no word from
Tim the Muller's first clue came from a gas station in Lake City Florida 150 Mi North on the day he disappeared Tim paid
for a tank of gas with his parents' credit card the recall that Tim had been traveling alone but traveling
where his family could only guess until they received the notice from a car impound yard in Georgia that is the
molers learned that 6 days after Tim left home his car was found abandoned in a parking lot just the block from the
Atlanta bus terminal when we went to inspect the car we did find his driver's license and
wallet and um some identification in our credit card which indicated to me that he
changed his identity and in other words he wanted to start a new life from there
on I worried mostly about Foul Play and was afraid that something happened to him because we have no proof that he
drove his car from Lake City Florida to Atlanta Tim molner left behind a tangle of conflicting Clues on one hand he
didn't take any clothes with him perhaps he had never really intended to stay away and yet just before leaving Tim
withdrew nearly all the money from his savings account he did however leave a balance of $10 as though to say he might
someday return I mean no matter where he is or what he's up to it'd be great to see him
and just you know tell we miss him and um you know kind of curious why he left what have you I'm sure you know I don't
know what the circumstances were but uh you know it' be great to see him update when this story first aired a
viewer recognized the clothing that Tim was wearing when he disappeared 10 years earlier the viewer
had discovered a body in the woods near meron Wisconsin with similar clothing DNA tests confirmed that the body was
that of Tim Muller police have no idea what Tim was doing in Wisconsin or how he died if you have any information
about the death of Tim mulner please log on to our website at UNS south.com [Music]
[Music]

Brief Summary

Clarence Roberts dies twice, Elvis's twin's impact, Wanda Jean's disappearance, Catherine Corzilius's tragic death, and a fugitive doctor case.

Key points

The Mysterious Deaths of Clarence Roberts. Clarence Roberts is found dead in a garage fire, only to be discovered again years later after another fire. How could the same man die twice?
Elvis Presley's Twin Brother. Few know that Elvis Presley had a twin brother who died at birth, impacting his life profoundly.
The Disappearance of Wanda Jean Maize. Wanda Jean Maize vanishes under mysterious circumstances, leaving behind blood and unanswered questions.
The Tragic Death of Catherine Corzilius. Catherine Corzilius, a six-year-old girl, is found dead just blocks from her home, shocking her family.
The Investigation Unfolds. As the investigation continues, disturbing theories about Catherine's death emerge.
Catherine's Mysterious Death. Catherine's tragic death raises questions about what truly happened in her final moments.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

I still think Clarence died in the first fire.

Doubts about the circumstances of Clarence's death.

2:40WatchMar 9, 2017

Tension

75/ 100High tension

More from True Crime Files

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.