The Wanda Beach Mystery That Still Haunts Australia | Forensic Files

It's here. Case File has officially entered its 10th year. I want to take a minute to extend a warm thank you to
everyone who has listened, supported, and stayed with the show over the past decade. When I made the first episode of
Case File, I had no real understanding of podcasting or audio production. My simple hope was that it might reach 100
listens. Fast forward a decade and I could never have imagined being in this position with over 330 episodes in the
case file catalog, a loyal global audience, and a small team joining me for the journey.
To mark the 10-year anniversary, I'd like to introduce you to Case File Archives, a series of special bonus
releases revisiting the earliest years of the show. To kick things off over the next eight weeks, counting down to the
new season, we'll be releasing a mix of fully re-recorded episodes from our first year of production along with
episodes that were previously only available to Patreon and premium supporters. Rest assured that these are additional
bonus releases and will not replace our standard schedule, which is set to resume on March 7 this year.
We also want to reassure you that we'll still be releasing the same number of new Case File episodes this year as we
did in 2025. The Case File Archive series is strictly bonus content in the leadup to the new
season as a way to mark our 10th year. The rerun episodes have been completely edited, polished, re-recorded, and
freshly produced from start to finish to match our current production standards.
They are not complete rewrites. Our goal wasn't to alter the cases or reshape the
writing, but to preserve the original storytelling while giving the production the refinement it didn't have when I
started the show back in 2016. Where appropriate, updates have been added, but the core structure and
storytelling remain faithful to the originals. Because of this, these re-releases may
sound a little different to our recent episodes, but they allow us to bring some of the earliest episodes up to the
technical quality listeners expect today. We're beginning the series with the newly re-recorded Wonder Beach case.
This was the very first episode of Case File. We are releasing it today on January 9th, 2026, exactly 10 years
after the original episode first aired on January 9th, 2016. It also comes just 2 days before the
61st anniversary of the crime. Throughout our 10th year, our goal is to release episodes most weeks of the year,
with this case file archives bonus series providing additional material alongside our new episodes. It's a way
for us to reflect on those early cases and rehighlight stories that many newer listeners may have missed. Whether
you've been listening since the start or have only just tuned in, myself and the
rest of the case team thank you for joining us. We couldn't have done it without you.
Our episodes deal with serious and often distressing incidents. If you feel at any time you need support, please
contact your local crisis center. For suggested phone numbers, for confidential support, and for a more
detailed list of content warnings, please see the show notes for this episode on your app or on our website.
On January 12th, 1965, the bodies of 15year-olds Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik were found on a
desolate and isolated stretch of beach just north of Krenella in Sydney South. The case would come to be known as the W
Beach murders. One mention of the word wonder is enough to send chills down the spine of those
who remember the case that dominated the television reports, radio airwaves, and
print media of the day. The killing sparked one of the biggest manhunts Australia has ever seen. The
police file on the case is over 10,000 pages long and over 14,000 people have been interviewed.
Efforts to solve the case have been exhaustive and leads have been followed up all around Australia.
The case raised many questions. What drew Maryanne and Christine to the Wander Sand Hills that day? Had they
arranged to meet someone, or were they in the wrong place at the wrong time? Speculation and theories have surrounded
the case since day one, but only one thing is clear. A vicious and ruthless killer has never
been brought to justice. Welcome to Case File, true crime podcast. Case one, the Wonder Beach
murders. In 1958, married couple Helmut and Elizabeth Schmidt decided to migrate to
Australia from their hometown in Germany. They made the journey along with their six children, Helmouth Jr.,
Maryanne, Hans, Peter, Wolf Gang, and Trixie. Upon their arrival, the family stayed in
various migrant camps and soon welcomed a seventh child, a boy named Norbert, before eventually settling down into a
home of their own on Brush Road in the Sydney suburb of Northride. 13-year-old Maryanne Schmidt quickly
struck up a friendship with her nextdoor neighbor, Christine Sherik, who was the
same age. Christine lived with her grandparents, Jim and Janette, choosing to do so after
her father passed away and her mother remarried. Christine and Maryanne formed an instant
bond, sharing a love of the beach and music with a particular fondness for Elvis.
The two became inseparable. Reflecting on their friendship later on, Christine's uncle said they did not go
out much and their main interests were centered around their homes. They were always in each other's company, and
neither went out with boys. Both girls were described as being good students and regular churchgoers who
were quiet and well- behaved. They weren't known to hang around any unsaavory characters.
In 1964, Helmwood Senior passed away after a battle with Hodkdins disease. One can only imagine how much tighter
Maryanne and Christine's bond became, having both lost their fathers at such a young age.
By 1965, Maryanne and Christine were both 15 and closer than ever. On New Year's Day, the two friends visited
Krenella Beach, a popular spot located around 30 km south of Sydney CBD. Although the journey took around 2 hours
each way, it was the only Sydney beach accessible by train at the time, and therefore, it was the only beach the
teenagers ever visited. During this trip, they walked a little further north to the less crowded Wander
Beach, where they strolled through the sand hills. The next day, Maryanne visited Krenella
Beach again, this time with her brothers and sisters. She went off on her own for several
hours, and when she returned, she told her siblings she had gone for a walk to W Beach.
She didn't say why. Around the same time, Maryanne's mother, Elizabeth Schmidt, was admitted to
hospital to undergo an operation. She left her eldest children, Helmut Jr. and Maryanne in charge of the household
while she recovered. On January 9, Maryanne and Christine visited Elizabeth in hospital, and
Maryanne asked if they could take some of her siblings to Krenella Beach the following day.
Elizabeth gave them permission to do so, but the next day the weather was terrible. So, Maryanne and Christine
decided to postpone their plan. The trip went ahead the following morning on Monday, January 11, 1965.
While getting ready, Christine told her grandmother, Janette, that it would be fun to walk along the Wonder Sand Hills
again. Janette urged her not to, replying, "Don't go today, love. You've got the
four little ones with you. It's too far." Christine tried to argue, but again, her
grandmother warned her against it. So, what are the Wonder Sand Hills and what was the girl's fascination with
them? Wonder is an Aboriginal name meaning sand hills by the sea beach. Wonder beach is part of a longer stretch
of coastline that starts with Kanala Beach and includes North Kanala Beach, Allura Beach, and then Wonder Beach.
The Wander Sand Hills, otherwise known as Green Hills, run behind Wonder Beach and continue north up to the Sydney
suburb of Kernel. The distance from Krenala Beach to the W sand hills is about 2 km.
While the main part of Wonder Beach itself was clean and pristine back in 1965, the isolated sand hills were a different
story entirely. The sand hills were described as being Sydney's filthiest and loneliest stretch
of beach, littered with smashed bottles, old shoes, rusted cans, broken toys, and
all kinds of discarded junk and rubbish. Regardless, the isolation meant the Wonder Sand Hills were popular for
people wanting to meet up without being seen. Given that homosexuality was illegal at
the time, certain areas of the Sand Hills were popular with gay men who wanted to engage in casual sex.
The area was also known to attract nude sunbathers, couples engaging in public sex, public [ __ ] voyers, and
men who harassed women and propositioned them for sex. Access to the sand hills could be gained without having to walk
along the main beach areas by either parking behind the hills or following a number of trails.
Many local residents were aware of what went on in the sand hills and refused to
let their children anywhere near them. It obviously didn't sound like the ideal place for two well- behaved teenagers
like Maryannne Schmidt and Christine Sherik, but they weren't from the local area and therefore were likely unaware
of its reputation. Back then, information wasn't as readily available and didn't travel anywhere
near as fast as it does today. And so on that morning of Monday, January 11, the two friends got ready
for their day at the beach. Christine packed a thermos of cordial and a£1 note to buy lunch with later on
while Maryanne packed some sandwiches and fruit. At 8:30 a.m., the two teenagers walked to the West Ride train
station along with Maryanne's 9-year-old sister, Trixie, and her brothers, 10-year-old Peter, 7-year-old Wolf Gang,
and 5-year-old Norbert. The other two Schmidt boys, Hilmer Jr. and Hans, stayed home to complete some
household chores. The journey to Krenella required the group to change trains once they reached
Red Fern Station. As they began their first leg of the trip, a tall teenage boy who looked to
be around 15 years old struck up a conversation with Maryanne and Christine. What they talked about isn't known, but
the boy didn't follow them when they switched stations, and the girls didn't talk to anyone else for the rest of the
journey. The group arrived at Krenella Beach at around 11:00 a.m. only to find out that
the beach was closed due to dangerous seas and strong winds. Undeterred, they headed to the southern
end of Kronella Beach and hung around the rocks. Wolf Gang kept pestering Maryanne to
take him for a swim, and eventually she gave in and took him to a shallow and more secluded spot for a quick dip
before they rejoined the others to eat lunch on the rocks. At some point, Wolf Gang saw Maryanne
and Christine talking to a boy who was hunting for crabs with a homemade spear. He looked to be around 16 years old and
was of medium build with long fair hair. Wolf Gang couldn't hear what they were talking about.
Shortly after lunch, Maryanne suggested they all take a walk to the W sand hills
and the others agreed. They left their belongings at the rocks and began the 2 km journey north.
Once they reached a Wander Beach, the walk became too much for the younger children.
The wind was howling and it was whipping the sand up and stinging their legs. Wolf Gang found a spot that was
sheltered from the wind. Maryanne and Christine told the younger kids to stay there while they walked back to the
rocks and grabbed their belongings so they could go home, saying it should only take them about 20 minutes.
However, it didn't appear that the pair had any intention of going home just yet.
Instead of walking south, they continued north to the sand hills. Peter yelled out to them, "You're going
the wrong way." But the girls just looked back and laughed, continuing on into the sand
hills. About 10 minutes later, Peter sent Wolf Gang out to look for the girls. Wolf Gang walked to the sand hills and
saw Maryanne and Christine talking to a teenage boy who looked to be about 16 years old.
He was a quote big boy with tanned skin, long light colored hair, and white sun cream on his nose.
He wore gray trousers with no shirt and carried a blue towel. Wolf Gang thought he looked like a
surfy. He looked angry and was asking Maryanne and Christine for their names. The girls followed the surfy into the
sand hills and Wolf Gang decided not to follow them any further. About 10 minutes later, Wolf Gang saw
the surfy looking teenager walking out of the sand hills alone. His blue towel was now tied around his
neck. Wolf Gang asked the teen, "Where are the girls?" But he walked straight past
without answering. We can only speculate as to why Maryanne and Christine walked into the sand hills
that day, but it does seem clear that they were determined to go there. Not only had Christine mentioned the plan to
her grandmother, but they had also persevered with taking the young children on the long walk despite the
poor weather conditions. Because of this, many were later convinced that the girls had planned to
meet someone at the Sand Hills that day. However, Maryanne and Christine had originally planned to go to the beach on
the Sunday, the day before, and those plans had only changed at the last minute due to the bad weather.
Back then, in the days before mobile phones and social media, it wasn't as easy to reschedu as it is today.
If they did go to the Sand Hills with the intention of meeting someone, it is possible that it was someone who they
had come into contact with that Monday. After Wolf Gang lost sight of Christine and Maryanne, a man named Dennis Dostine
saw the pair hurrying through the sand hills. One of them kept looking over her shoulder as though someone was following
them, but Dennis couldn't see anyone else, and he didn't think much more of it. Meanwhile, the Schmidt siblings
continued to wait. Eventually, they went looking for Maryanne and Christine, but couldn't
find them. At no stage did Wolf Gang mention the Surfy teenager to the others. After a few hours, the children realized
that time was slipping away, and the last train out of Kronala would be leaving at 6:00 p.m.
They made the decision to head home without Marianne and Christine, trudging back down to the southern end of
Krenella Beach, where their belongings still sat untouched. They boarded the last train out of
Krenella and arrived home after 8:00 p.m., informing both families that the two girls were missing.
No great alarm bells went off for the police who attended to take the missing person's report. After all, the two
friends had happily walked off at their own free will. The officers asked the usual questions.
Have they done this before? Is there anywhere you think they might be? Do they have boyfriends? etc. Their only
concern stemmed from the fact that Maryanne and Christine both came from happy homes and had never run off
before. It was completely out of character for either of them to go off without telling
anyone, and even stranger that they would leave the younger children alone at the beach.
A description of the pair was broadcast to all police stations in the Sydney area. Just imagine how different it was
in 1965. There were no mobile phones to track, no social media accounts to check, no
instant media releases that could go viral to keep the public on the lookout. But even if all that modern technology
was available, it would have been too late. At around 2:30 p.m. on Tuesday, January
12th, 17-year-old Peter Smith was walking through the Wonder Sand Hills with his two younger nephews when he saw
what looked like a store mannequin lying in the sand. A closer inspection revealed the grim
reality. Filled with shock and panic, Peter ran to the W Surf Club, which was about
1,500 m south. He notified the caretaker that he had found the body of a teenage girl and
asked to use the phone to call the police. Police arrived at the surf club and Peter led them to the site in the sand
hills. Upon closer inspection, a police officer noticed that there were actually three
feet sticking out from under the sand. The shocking discovery became that much more horrific when it was discovered
that there wasn't just one body, but two. Local Krenella detectives soon notified
the criminal investigation branch and homicide detectives made their way to Wander along with forensic
investigators. The crime scene was thoroughly examined and portable lighting was brought in as
the work continued into the night. It didn't take long for police to link the gruesome discovery to the missing
person report for Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik, and a positive identification was made.
The location where the girls bodies were found was two dunes back from where they
had first wandered off, 150 m from the water's edge and about 1,500 m north of Wander Surf Club.
Maryanne's brother, Hans, who hadn't gone to the beach with the group, visited the crime scene and described
the area. "The place the girls were killed, was very isolated, even though it was only
two dunes back from the beach," he said. "It was so quiet, I couldn't even hear the waves crashing. You could scream
your head off and no one would hear a thing. No one could have heard the girls screaming for help.
From the location where the girl's bodies were found, there was a 32 m long drag mark in the sand which led to blood
stains and signs of a struggle. The lead detective concluded, quote, "It looks as though the Schmidt girl was
knocked down and then stabbed. Christine was killed about 20 yard away and her body was then dragged back to where the
Schmidt girl lay." He believed Christine may have witnessed Maryanne being attacked and then ran off
only to be caught a short distance away. Every 3 m in the drag marks, there were
much heavier concentrations of blood. This indicated that whoever was dragging Christine's body had stopped for a rest
at certain intervals. Given that Christine was described as a petite girl, this implied that the
perpetrator may not have been very strong. About 30 m west of where Christine was
attacked, detectives located car tire tracks, but they couldn't say with certainty whether the tracks were
related to the crime. It was also possible that the killer had escaped on foot over the back of the
sand hills towards Captain Cook Drive without ever going back to the beach. Postmortems revealed that Christine and
Maryanne had both been savagely attacked and mutilated. The official cause of Christine's death
was hemorrhage as a result of penetrating wounds to the chest associated with a fracture of the skull
and injury to the brain. Maryanne's official cause of death was hemorrhage as a result of a cut throat
and penetrating wounds to the chest. There were signs that both girls had been sexually assaulted.
Seaman was also found on Maryanne's body. The attack was so savage that the full
details have never been released to the public. The time of death for both girls was
estimated to be between 2:00 p.m. and midnight on Monday, January 11, 1965. The exact time was difficult to pinpoint
as both of their bodies had been covered by hot sand. An examination of Christine's stomach
contents revealed that she had undigested cabbage and celery in her system. This immediately stood out to
investigators as the group had only taken sandwiches and fruit to the beach and Christine hadn't eaten anything
containing these ingredients while with the others. For the food to be undigested, it meant
she had eaten within 1 hour of her death. Christine also had a blood alcohol reading of 0.015.
This was the equivalent of either drinking about a midi of beer or a nip of spirits just prior to her death or
the culmination of drinking several drinks in the hours leading up to her death.
The time she had consumed the alcohol couldn't be accurately determined, but the reading of 0.015 would have been
accurate at the time she died and wouldn't have changed thereafter. Maryanne, on the other hand, had no
alcohol in her system. This revelation horrified Christine's grandmother as Christine was not known
to drink. Her family stated that she had never touched alcohol and couldn't even
stand the smell. Loud alarm bells were going off. The food found in Christine's stomach didn't
match what they had brought to the beach, and they certainly hadn't taken any alcohol with them.
Given that the food in Christine's stomach was consumed within 1 hour of her death, it was likely that Christine
had shared food and alcohol with her killer. The injuries the girls had sustained led
police to believe they were looking for a fishing knife. They were also looking for a heavy blunt
instrument that was used to inflict the injuries on Christine, such as a rock, a
lump of wood, or a piece of metal pipe. The police questioned Wolf Gang, Peter, Trixie, and Norbert Schmidt extensively.
On Wednesday, January 13, the children were taken to the Sand Hills to retrace their steps and provide as much
information as possible about what had happened during their visit on Monday. Tragically, at this point, they were
still unaware that Maryanne and Christine were dead. It was at this point that detectives
first learned that 7-year-old Wolf Gang had seen the surfily looking teenager talking to the girls before they
disappeared into the sand hills. He'd first mentioned it to one of his older brothers while they were at home
waiting for news about Maryanne's whereabouts. None of the other children recalled
seeing the Surfy. Wolf Gang's account was the first major piece of information that detectives had
to go by, and the hunt for the Surfy teenager began. Media reports on the TV, radio, and
newspaper were dominated with details about the suspect last seen with Maryanne and Christine just prior to
their deaths. The problem was the description of the surfy matched just about every teenage
boy in the Krenal and Southerntherland Shire area. In a bid to make sure other potential
persons of interest didn't fly under the radar for not matching this description,
the police were quick to point out that they didn't necessarily believe the Surfy was the murderer.
It didn't take long before the police were swamped with hundreds of calls each day about the Surfy.
The caretaker of the W Surf Club revealed that on the Thursday before the murders, he had kicked a teenager who
matched that description off the beach for harassing two young girls. The media ran wild and the police
commissioner made a public appeal for the Surfy to come forward. With the hunt in full swing, the media
reported that four teenage suspects had been detained. One of them as far away as Queensland, and they were each being
questioned. The truth was that they weren't suspects in the W Beach murders at all, but just
teenagers who had been arrested on other minor matters. The fact that they may have looked like surfies was enough for
some people to label them as suspects. A mammoth search of the crime scene and surrounding Wonder Sand Hills commenced.
Police, including trainees, were sent from all over Sydney to help. The search wasn't easy. The filthy nature of the
Sand Hills with all the discarded rubbish hampered the search for clues immensely.
Several items were located, including shoes and even knives, but they were quickly ruled out as having anything to
do with the murders. By Thursday, January 14, police had secured a front-end loader from
Southerntherland Shia Council so they could dig up the sand, which was then put through a sift.
Army experts with metal and mine detectors were even sent to help. They dug up 500 tons of sand, but found
very little to assist their investigation. The only piece of physical evidence that
was located was a broken piece of a knife blade that was believed to have come from a kitchen knife.
The piece of blade was about 1 in long and had a clear cutting edge. It tested positive for blood. However,
there was an insufficient amount to conduct any further testing. Even if there was, DNA testing didn't
exist at the time and wouldn't for another 21 years. A forensic pathologist later testified
that the stab wounds inflicted on Maryanne and Christine would have been difficult to inflict with this
particular piece of broken blade. Although he did say that some cut marks on Christine could have been made with a
knife that had a portion of its blade missing. It was ultimately unclear if this piece
of blade was part of the murder weapon and had broken off during the savage attack or if it was completely
unrelated. On January 15, Maryanne's mother, Elizabeth Schmidt, broke her silence
about the murders. She was still in hospital recovering from her operation, having been allowed
temporary leave to comfort her children after news of Maryanne's death broke. In
a heartbreaking interview, Elizabeth said, quote, "My daughter and the other young girl have gone into eternal life.
They have met their maker and have therefore entered a new phase of existence. The person responsible, the murderer,
has his life ahead of him. How he faces this life is something I cannot answer. But his life would appear to be
spiritually speaking poorer than anything else. He would always be hunted and taunted.
The man responsible should meet his punishment and I think my husband would have felt the same way.
He should be made responsible for his action. At this time, the police commissioner
renewed his appeal for the Surfy teenager described by Wolf Gang Schmidt to come forward.
Reports had been circulating in the media that the Surfy was the killer, but the commissioner clarified, quote, "He
should not be influenced by published statements. He could very well clear the air for us in our investigations."
The next day, the commissioner made another appeal, stating, "I renew my appeal to this youth to come
forward and tell us what happened last Monday." Because he was seen coming away alone from the scene, it does not
necessarily follow that he is the killer. He stressed that police believed the Surfy could have been an innocent
bystander who was at the wrong place at the wrong time. if he'd just come and talk to the
police, they could clear him of suspicion. By this stage, police had interviewed
over 20 people who had been at the beach on Monday, January 11. More than 40 detectives had been assigned to the case
fulltime in what was shaping up to be one of the biggest manhunts Australia had ever seen.
Reports of individuals who matched the description of the surfy teenager were continuing to come in from all over the
state and even the country. Police were receiving hundreds of calls a day and were struggling to keep up
with the amount of information that was coming in. Some felt that a vital tip off may have
been lost amongst the thousands of calls that were received. Both Maryanne and Christine kept the
diaries. And through those diaries, police learned that when the girls had visited the beach together on New Year's
Day of 1965, they had met and kissed two boys. On January 16, police made a public
appeal for those two boys to come forward. And they did. known only as Ted and Jim. The two teens
were interviewed by police and confirmed they had met Maryanne and Christine at the beach on New Year's Day. However,
they said they hadn't made any plans to meet up again. Both of their alibis checked out and Ted
and Jim were quickly ruled out of the investigation. On January 18, one week after the
murders, news reports ran wild that a teenage boy was being held by police after a pair of bloodstained trousers
were found on Kuji Beach and identified as belonging to him. Wolf Gang Schmidt was rushed to Randwick
Police Station where a lineup was conducted, but he didn't identify the teenager as the surfy he had seen on the
day of the murders. It turned out that the individual had a simple explanation for the blood being
on his trousers, and it was confirmed that he wasn't at Wonder Beach on January 11.
Meanwhile, detectives were being flooded with information about several other suspicious males who had been seen at
the beach on the day of and days leading up to the murders. A sketch artist was brought in to assist
witnesses. By this point, Wolf Gang Schmidt had revealed another detail. He said that the surfy he'd seen talking
to the girls on the day of the murders was the same boy who had been hunting for crabs at the rocks earlier that day
and had struck up a conversation with the girls. Police made an appeal for the crab
hunter to come forward with his description more or less matching that of the surfy.
On January 20, separate funeral services were held for Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik.
The service for Maryanne was held in the West Chapel of the Metropolitan Funeral
Home at Burwood and she was then cremated at Rookwood Crematorium. The service for Christine was held at
St. Michael's Catholic Church in Meadow Bank and she was then buried at Liverpool Cemetery near her father.
Both services attracted hundreds of mourners. Detectives and police photographers were
also in attendance, working on the theory that the girls knew their killer and that he may be at their funerals.
Just about every male who attended was photographed. At Maryanne's service, two teenage
sisters were interviewed separately by detectives after their father alerted police that they may have some valuable
information concerning Maryanne and Christine's backgrounds. Detectives were very interested to hear
what the girls had to say, but unfortunately no light was thrown on the investigation.
By this stage, a number of suspicious people had been reported as being on the beach on January 11, and police were
interested in speaking to each one. Dennis Dostine, the last known person to have seen Christine and Maryanne alive,
also reported seeing a number of other people around the same time he saw the two girls.
Of particular interest to police was a tall 19-year-old male with pale skin and a stocky male between the ages of 40 and
50 with tanned leathery skin. 57-year-old Francis Williams had been at the beach on January 11, and he came
forward to report having seen Christine, Maryanne, and the youngest Schmidt children at around 100 p.m.
They were walking north along the beach towards W about 100 m from the W Surf Club. Francis thought that they were
walking quite quickly and looked to be in a hurry. He also described a number of other
people he saw around Wander that day, including a male who was sunbathing in the sand hills. As Francis had
approached him, the male got up, shook sand off him, and walked off towards Wand Surf Club.
Two young boys who were playing on the beach. Two people fishing on the beach, a man
sunbathing with a corrugated iron box over his head. When some people heard this, they
immediately jumped to the conclusion that this man was one of the many perverts who lurked around the wand sand
hills. However, given it was a windy day, it's also possible that he was just using the box to protect his head from
the windb blown sand. a woman who had become bogged in the sand just behind the sand hills. She was
assisted by Francis. And lastly, another unknown male who drove off in a utility.
The details of these eight people were released to the media with some immediate success.
Upon seeing the report, the woman who was bogged came forward, but she was unable to add anything to the
investigation. None of the remaining seven people came forward. Given what the Wander Sand Hills were
renowned for at the time, it is believed that many people were too scared to come
forward out of fear that the police would question them as to what they were doing in the area that day.
On January 22, an interesting article was published in the Sydney Morning Herald. It was only very small and
buried on page 10, overshadowed by the other stories that were now dominating the news, such as Winston Churchill's
declining health and the Rolling Stones visit to Australia. Buried amongst these other articles, a
small headline read, "Wonder victim's claim lapses." The article reported that Maryanne
Schmidt had been struck by a car on the corner of Victoria Road and Brush Road at Ride on May 7, 1964.
She suffered a fractured skull and had spent 9 days in hospital, after which she submitted a compensation claim of
£20,000. Australia was still using the pound as currency at the time, and this was quite
a significant sum, the equivalent of over half a million in 2016. The claim was due to be heard later on
in 1965, but as a result of Maryanne's death, the article confirmed that the claim had elapsed and would not proceed
any further. That same day, the police commissioner made yet another appeal. Quote,
"I have on more than one occasion asked the public to assist in every way within
their power with information which might help detectives engaged on the case. I now make a further and equally sincere
appeal. I do this because I am satisfied that there must be some persons in the community who would have some
information they have not brought to the notice of police. It is not unreasonable to assume that
someone somewhere in our community has seen or heard something which would be of great assistance in this matter.
For example, since this crime, a person may not have been seen at places he used
to frequent or there has been a change in pattern of his normal activity and behavior.
It is possible that to someone's knowledge he has said or done something which would give rise to a reasonable
suspicion that he might have been in some way associated with the crime. That is the type of vital information we
would like to get. Police were still searching for the seven people that Francis Williams had
seen at the beach on January 11. On January 23, a sketch of Wonder Beach and the surrounding sand hills was
released to the public. It showed the location of the crime scene as well as the various locations
where the seven unidentified people had been seen. Multiple people came forward to report
having been at the beach that day, completely unaware of just how close to the crime scene they had actually been.
But none of the people Francis had seen came forward. A psychiatrist released a report
revealing that they believed the killer lived local to the area. He likely had intimate knowledge of the Sand Hills and
could have been one of the so-called perverts who frequented the area. The psychiatrist said the killer was
likely a loner who had spent time at the Wonder Sand Hills spying on nude sunbathers and people having sex.
They felt the crimes were committed on impulse and that the killer may have acted on a previous urge after seeing
Maryanne and Christine during their earlier visits to the Sand Hills. The investigation into the murders was
hampered by the lack of physical evidence and identifiable witnesses as well as the unwillingness of people to
come forward. Hoping to overcome this, on January 29, the New South Wales premier announced a
£10,000 reward for any information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person responsible.
The currency changed to dollars soon after and the reward switched to $20,000, roughly the equivalent of a quarter of a
million in 2016. Two girls came forward to report that they had been riding horses on the beach
on January 11 when they saw a naked man walking around the sand hills with his clothes in his hands.
It was about 400 m from where Maryanne and Christine were killed. One of the girls yelled out, "What are
you doing?" But the man ignored them and kept walking. He was added to the growing list of
unidentified people seen at the beach that day. Police officers had been assigned to
keep watch on the sand hills round the clock in case the killer returned. On February 1, they thought they'd made
a breakthrough when one of these officers located a blue towel washed up on Wonder Beach.
This was significant because the surfy teenager described by Wolf Gang Schmidt had been carrying a blue towel.
The towel was immediately sent for scientific testing, but it became another frustrating dead end when a
13-year-old boy came forward and identified the towel as one he had lost at the beach only a few days earlier.
The large reward was encouraging all types of people to call in, and the police were inundated with false leads,
dead ants, hoax callers, and fake confessions. By March, anyone who resembled a surfy
teenager had been reported to the police. As the weeks passed by, Wolf Gang Schmidt added yet another detail. He
told the police that when the surfy walked off into the sand hills with Marianne and Christine, he had a knife
in a pouch around his waist. When he walked back out alone 10 minutes later, the knife was missing.
Wolf Gang's story had evolved over several interviews, and he'd added vital pieces of information as time went on.
It was a source of frustration for detectives and his version of events was treated with some skepticism.
Why Wolf Gang's story changed numerous times is anyone's guess, but his father had just died. His mother had just had a
serious operation, and his sister had just been brutally murdered. The amount of stress, trauma, fear, and grief the
7-year-old would have experienced is almost inconceivable, and he was most likely in severe shock.
There was no grief counseling at the time, and people were expected to just suck it up. It's not surprising if his
memory was a bit muddled. By April, 3 months had passed, and there still hadn't been any breakthroughs.
On April 19, two 15year-old girls were walking together near Carringbar train station, a short distance from Kronala
when a 15-year-old male grabbed one of them. The girls immediately screamed and managed to frighten the boy off, but
their description of him was very similar to that of the Surfy provided by Wolf Gang, pushing an already frightened
community further towards the edge. Police remained frustrated by the fact that several of the people cited at the
beach on the day of the murders still refused to come forward. They released six sketches of the individuals they
were most interested in talking to. These included the naked man seen walking through the sand hills, a man
who had been exposing himself to women in the months after the murders, and the teenager who had just attacked the girls
at Carringbar. Wolf Gang Schmidt was unable to help police with a sketch of the Surfy. He
agreed with everything the sketch artist said, making it an impossible task. Police were also particularly interested
in speaking to two men who had been harassing women in the area. The first was aged between 25 and 35, roughly 5'
11 in tall and of medium to plump build. He had a quote slightly foreign appearance and was known to carry an
orange and white towel. On the day of the murders, as well as the days leading up to it, he had been
seen in the area wearing gray trousers and a white shirt and carrying a newspaper and radio.
He approached several women, showing them pornographic pictures and asking them questions of a sexual nature. He
told some of them that he was from South Australia. The other man was described as being
between 18 and 20 years old with a slim build, light brown hair, and missing teeth. He had been wearing a
long-sleeved shirt tucked into a pair of thorn colored shorts and was propositioning women on the beach for
sex. Neither of these men came forward, and they have never been identified. On May 29, a group of youths came
forward to reveal that just a few days after Maryanne and Christine were murdered, they had found a pair of
flippers and a homemade crab spear about 1 kilometer from the crime scene. They handed both of these items into the
police, though it's unclear why they waited 4 and 1/2 months to provide this information.
Wolf Gang Schmidt was reintered, but he couldn't remember if the spear was the same as the one he had seen the teenage
boy hunting for crabs with on the day of the murders. The investigation continued throughout
the year and into 1966, but it was starting to stall. The amount of full-time detectives assigned to the
case dropped from 40 to 8. Police were still assigned to keep watch on the Wonders Sand Hills. And while this had
resulted in a number of people being charged with sexual related offenses, police were no closer to identifying
Maryanne and Christine's killer. On January 29, 1966, just after the 1-year anniversary of the murders,
another brutal crime shocked the nation. 57-year-old Willilamina Krueger was found stabbed to death at the Piccadilly
Shopping Arcade in Wllingong, where she worked as a cleaner. She was killed in the early hours of the morning between
4:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. Willamina's murder was horrific and bore similarities to the Wander case, a
frenzied knife attack, no suspects, no witnesses, and no attempt at hiding her body.
Given that Wulingong is less than an hour's drive from Wand Beach, some believed that both murders were
committed by the same person. Just weeks later, on February 26th, 1966, the body of 27-year-old Anna
Dalinka was found on the old Ilawar Road in the suburb of Meni in Sydney's south.
Again, the location was in close enough proximity to both Wonder Beach and Wllingong. And Anna had been the victim
of a frenzied knife attack that was almost identical to the one committed against Willamina Krueger. Anna was a
sex worker and was last seen leaving a club in King's Cross after mentioning she was meeting a client.
Again, there were no witnesses, no suspects, no physical evidence, and no attempt to hide the body.
Police were almost certain the murders of Willamina Krueger and Anna Dalinkoa were committed by the same person.
Although links to the Wonder Beach case have never been proven, some have speculated that the same person might
have committed all four murders. The murders of Willamina and Anna remain unsolved.
Their stories were covered in detail on episode 72 of Case File. On April 20, 1966, a coronial inquest
into the deaths of Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik was held, presided over
by the city coroner. By this point, the number of detectives working the case full-time was down to
just six. The investigation log totaled over 5,000 pages and 7,000 interviews. Over 3 days, many witnesses gave
evidence, including the allimportant Schmidt children. The coroner believed there must be
somebody who could shed light on the murders. While he acknowledged that the police had already conducted exhaustive
inquiries, he hoped it was possible that the investigation could be intensified.
There was no doubt in the coroner's mind. Quote, "The cause of death is very evident. a vicious, brutal murder.
After the inquest, the police stated they would be reviewing every page of the case file in the hopes of uncovering
a vital piece of information that might have been previously overlooked. They still believed that somebody out
there knew something, but was withholding information, either because they were protecting someone close to
them or were fearful of that person. The investigation continued, but still no suspect was identified.
The six sketches that police had previously released were made into full-sized lifelike dummies, which were
displayed at the 1967 Sydney Easter show. It was hoped the large crowds of people would be able to put names to
faces, but no one could. On March 17, 1967, a 28-year-old woman named Brenda Galvin was sunbathing on
Wonder Beach with her three children when she was attacked by an unknown male. A witness named Trevor Betts rushed to
her aid, and the attacker fled in what was described as an old white vehicle. The description of the attacker provided
by both Brenda and Trevor matched one of the six unidentified police sketches, leading many to believe that the Wonder
Beach killer had attempted another attack. Despite an extensive investigation, this
offender was never identified. The years passed by with no major breakthroughs in the case, but new
persons of interest continued to emerge. When it comes to suspects in the murders
of Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik, three names are often thrown around. On Friday, June 10, 1966,
20-year-old Carolyn Mayor Orphan attended a dance in Wllingong, where she met 21-year-old Alan Basset, a fitter
and Turner from the nearby suburb of Yunandera. Caroline accepted a ride home from
Basset, who proceeded to kill her and dump her body on the side of a road. He was quickly identified and charged with
her murder. By all reports, Alan Basset seemed like a quiet, shy, and normal guy.
after he was arrested for Carolyn's murder. He claimed he had no idea what came over him and said he didn't mean to
kill her. Despite the fact that she was tied up, strangled, and hit over the head with a
large rock, Basset asked to be found guilty of manslaughter. Although there were notable differences
between Carolyn's murder and that of Christine Sherik, Maryanne Schmidt, Willilamina Krueger, and Anna Delanca,
some considered Alan Basset to be a prime suspect in those cases as well. There was the savage nature of the
attack on Carolyn combined with the fact that Unandera was only a 5-minute drive
from the Piccadilly shopping arcade where Willilamina was killed and within an hour's reach of Menai and Wonder
Beach. Further investigations led police to believe that Alan Basset was at Kronala
around the time that Maryanne and Christine were murdered. A detective named Cess Johnson, who
worked the WonderB case, grew so convinced of Alan Basset's involvement in all four unsolved murders that he
became obsessed with getting Basset to confess. His obsession was so strong that it
turned unhealthy, and it was even recommended that he resign from the force. After his conviction for Carolyn's
murder, Basset was diagnosed with schizophrenia and sent to Moriceet Psychiatric Hospital near Newcastle.
Detective Ces Johnson visited him regularly and became even more convinced of his theory after Basset gave him a
painting he had drawn. The detective didn't think much of it at first, considering it to be quite an ugly
looking thing. But one day, he took a closer look at the painting and thought it depicted the
Wonder Beach crime scene and contained a clue that only the killer could know. Whatever that clue was has never been
made public. Detective Johnson went to the press with his theory and even started writing a
book, but he was killed in an accident before it was complete. While some agreed with Detective
Johnson's theory, many others did not. Privately, they thought he'd become too obsessed with Basset and was seeing
things that weren't there. One person he did convince, however, was Alan Basset's father, who went on public
record saying that he believed his son was responsible for the Wonder Beach murders and should never be released.
In 1995, Alan Basset was released from custody and placed back in the community. He denied being involved in
any crime other than the murder of Carolyn Orphan. In the year 2000, Basset publicly
offered to provide a DNA sample to prove his innocence in the other cases, but whether or not the police took him up on
his offer is unknown. The second name emerged on April 13, 1984 after the death of a man in the
United States sparked the interest of the New South Wales police and prompted the Wonder Beach case to be re-examined.
The reason why the man was Christopher Wilder, a serial killer dubbed the beauty queen killer.
Wilder was born in Sydney in 1945 and was still living there at the time that Maryanne and Christine were killed.
Christopher Wilder's first major run-in with the law was 2 years before the Wonder Beach murders at the age of 17
when he was charged for the gang rape of a woman at another Sydney beach. He got
off with probation and electric shock therapy. In 1968, Wilder got married, but his
wife left him a week later, claiming sexual and physical abuse. In 1969, he lured a 19-year-old nursing
student to Manly Beach and convinced her to pose for nude photographs. He then tried to force her to have sex
with him, and when she refused, he threatened to blackmail her with the photos. The woman escaped and contacted police
but declined to testify against him. Later that year, Wilder immigrated to the United States and settled in
Florida. It didn't take him long to find significant wealth due to the booming construction and real estate industries.
In 1971, he had his first run-in with the American authorities after he was caught trying to entice women to pose
for nude photographs. The following year, he was arrested for trying to force a 16-year-old girl to
have oral sex with him, but he was later acquitted of this charge. A few years later, Wilder posed as a
photographer to lure a school girl out of a shopping mall before drugging and raping her.
He was somehow able to plea bargain this charge down to probation and therapy. In 1982, Wilder visited his parents in
Australia where he abducted two 15year-old girls, tied them up, and forced them to pose for nude
photographs. He was arrested soon after, and his parents posted his bail. Wilder was allowed to leave Australia
until his trial. And it was during this weight in 1984 that he commenced a murderous rampage across nine different
states of America, kidnapping a dozen women and killing eight. His MMO was to pose as a photographer and tell a girl
how beautiful she was and how he could help her launch a modeling career. Once he convinced a girl to go with him to
take photos, he'd then kill her. It's pretty obvious why some people think Christopher Wilder is a prime
suspect for the Wonder Beach murders. He was 19 at the time, living in Sydney and
turned out to be a serial killer. Although he was slightly older than the surfy teenager described by Wolf Gang
Schmidt, his physical description matched. However, his criminal timeline doesn't
seem to match up. Wilder committed a string of sexual offenses for many years before
escalating to murder in 1984, 19 years after Maryanne and Christine were killed.
This doesn't fit the behavioral trajectory of most known serial killers. Once a serial offender crosses the
threshold to murder, they rarely deescalate back to lesser offenses. This is what Walder would have had to do
if he was involved in the Wonder Beach killings, which would be almost unheard of.
Then again, Walder has also been suspected of being involved in the unsolved abduction and murder of several
women both in the United States and Australia well before 1984. This includes the 1974 murder of
18-year-old Trudy Adams in Sydney. However, no definitive links to these crimes have ever been proven.
By 1984, Wilder had become one of America's most wanted men. During a confrontation with police, he wounded an
officer before he himself was shot dead. After his death, New South Wales police
reopened the Wonder Beach case to examine any possible links between Wilder and the Wonder Murders. They also
requested a blood sample from Wilder in the hopes that advances in technology may one day prove whether or not he was
involved. The third name, and the one that's probably thrown around the most when it
comes to the murders of Maryanne and Christine, is Derek Percy. Percy has been described as Australia's
Hannibal Lectar, which tells you just about all you need to know about him. Many consider him to be the chief
suspect in not only the W Beach murders, but a number of other unsolved crimes against children committed around
Australia in the late 1960s. Among them is the murder of 6-year-old Alan Redston in Canra, 3-year-old Simon
Brookke in Sydney, and 7-year-old Linda Stillwell in Melbourne. Some also suspect he may have been
involved in the disappearance of the three Bowmont children in Adelaide, as was later covered in episode 100 of Case
File. So, who is Derek Percy? He was born in the inner western Sydney suburb of Strathfield on September 15,
1948. In 1956, he moved to Victoria with his family, and they spent the next few
years living in different parts of the state before moving to Mount Beauty in the state's northeast.
In 1964, women's underwear started to disappear off clothes lines and from inside houses around the Mount Beauty
area. There were whispers around town that 16-year-old Derek Percy was responsible.
He was known to be a bit of a loner who was hard to get to know. This suspicion was never proven until
later that year when two of his schoolmates made their way to a popular swimming hall and saw something so
unsettling that no one believed their story. It was Derek Percy walking around dressed in a woman's pett coat. Percy
didn't see the other boys, so they decided to hide and see what he was doing. They watched as Percy pulled out a knife
and started stabbing a pair of women's underpants that he had with him. Once he was done, he defecated into the river
and then walked off, taking the women's clothing with him. The boys questioned Percy about it at
school, but he denied it and claimed he had no idea what they were talking about. The other kids didn't really
believe the story either. They knew Percy was a bit different, but stabbing a pair of women's underpants
like that seemed to be a stretch. Around this time, Percy started keeping journals in which he wrote about
explicit sexual fantasies involving children. It was the beginning of an extremely
dark path. By 1966, Derek Percy was living in the small New South Wales town of Canobin,
just north of the Victorian border. He lured the two young girls who lived next door to him, the youngest of whom
was just 6 years old, into a caravan and convinced them both to remove their pants.
The girl's father caught him, but decided not to notify the police, instead leaving it to Percy's father to
discipline his son. Derek's diary entries continued to get darker and increasingly violent.
One entry made at this time even detailed his plan to kidnap two girls and take them to a secluded place.
Percy joined the Navy in November 1967. And it was during his time as a naval officer that he abducted a 12-year-old
girl named Ivon Tui from Ski Beach in southern Victoria. Ivonne had gone for a walk with her
friend, 11-year-old Shane, but the pair had become briefly separated when Percy pounced.
He was holding Ivonne by knife point when Shane found them. Percy tried to abduct Shane, too, but Shane was
carrying a tomahawk for chopping firewood and used it to threaten Percy and escape.
Shane was able to describe Derek Percy and the car he was driving to the police and they captured him just hours later.
Percy was arrested at the nearby Flender's Naval Deo where he was based listening to a radio report about
Ivonne's disappearance and trying to wash her blood out of his clothes. Unfortunately, by this time, Ivonne was
already dead. A search of Percy's belongings revealed sickening journal entries and drawings
depicting the rape, torture, and murder of children. He even had an entry detailing his
desire to kidnap a young boy and girl, just as he had attempted to do a few hours earlier.
The murder of Avon Toui was one of the worst cases that hardened detectives had ever seen.
Derek Percy stood trial at the Melbourne Supreme Court in April 1970. After 6 days, he was found not guilty by
reason of insanity and was ordered to be kept in custody at the governor's leisure, or in other words,
indefinitely. Fortunately, that's where he remained until his death in 2013. Ivonne's murder was the only crime he
was ever charged with, but he was questioned and suspected in many others. Percy never confessed to any of the
other crimes, but he didn't exactly deny involvement either. During his incarceration, many more
drawings and diary entries were found that outlined his sick fantasies. One rape, torture, and murder journal
was so organized that it even had an index. Percy has been described as a sadistic
pedophile with a morbid and sexual attraction to feal matter who views killing as the ultimate sexual act.
We could do a whole podcast on Derek Percy and the other crimes he is linked to, which may happen in the future.
But the main question for today is was Percy involved in the murders of Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik.
There is no clear evidence linking him to Wonder Beach, but there is one loose circumstantial detail to suggest it's a
possibility. The Percy family had a keen interest in sailing. In January 1965, the national mothclass
regata was being held at Botney Bay Yacht Club, which isn't too far from Wonder Beach.
This is the very class of sailing the Percy's were interested in. It has been suspected, although never
proven, that the Percy family were in Sydney for this regata. Derek Percy would have been 16 at the
time. If they were indeed there, it is likely they would have been staying at Percy's
grandmother's house in Denniston, which is the neighboring suburb to West Ride. To get to the beach, he would have had
to travel on the exact same train line as Maryanne and Christine. Remember when they were approached by a
teenage male on the train between Ride and Dread Fern? Percy didn't fit the description of the
surfy teenager provided by Wolf Gang Schmidt, but some claim he was a match for one of the six suspect sketches
released by the police that were later turned into life-sized dummies. It was later revealed that when Percy's
journals were found, one contained a newspaper article about the Wonder Beach murders that had obscene comments
written on it. However, this was a rumor that had gotten a bit twisted. It was actually an article from Playboy
magazine titled Wicked Wander that had nothing at all to do with the murders. There is no evidence tying Derek Percy
to Wonder Beach. Some believe he is guilty while others don't. If he was involved, he took his secret
to the grave, and only advancements in DNA technology might be able to prove for sure if Percy was the Wonder Beach
killer. In 2012, there was a major break in the investigation when technological
advancements allowed police to retest the clothing worn by Marannne and Christine at the time they were killed.
They were in luck. Testing revealed a spot of blood belonging to a male. However, the DNA profile was so weak
that further testing couldn't be conducted. With the technology expected to advance
further in the years to come, it is hoped that a full DNA profile will be obtained in the future.
What about the seaman sample? The problem is that back in 1965, DNA testing didn't exist and police
could never have imagined the technologies that would one day be available. Unfortunately, this may have led to less
than ideal handling of the evidence, and at some point over the years, that seaman sample has been lost.
The status of the broken knife blade is unknown. While the original investigators had
determined there was blood on the knife, they couldn't test it any further. Advanced testing might be possible
today, but there is no information to confirm whether the piece of knife blade still exists or if testing has been
done. The Wonder Beach case has always remained open and the $20,000 reward is still available.
Incredibly, the figure has never been increased, not even to match inflation. It may be time for the reward to be
reviewed. Was Alan Basset, Christopher Wilder, or Derek Percy responsible for the Wonder
Beach murders? Or was it someone else entirely? Has his name already been given to
police, buried amongst the thousands of pages that make up the case file, or lost amongst the hundreds of calls that
were coming in daily and thousands of leads police had to chase down? Or is it someone completely unknown who
has managed to avoid detection all these years? Is there someone out there who was at
Wonder Beach that day and saw something but is still too scared to come forward?
Many think there is. A number of people seen at the beach never came forward and still haven't
been identified. 1965 was a different time. Not only was homosexuality still illegal and
considered a psychiatric disorder, society held a very dim view of some of the other behaviors that went on in the
Sand Hills. Thankfully, times have changed and we can only hope that if anyone did see or
hear anything, they might still be alive and come forward. While this person might think the
information they hold is insignificant, it could be the vital piece of the puzzle that's needed to finally solve
the case and bring answers to the families of Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik.
Unfortunately, since this episode first aired in 2016, there have been no major updates in the Wonder Beach
investigation. No further DNA advancements have been reported, no new testing announced, and
the $20,000 reward remains unchanged. 61 years on, the case continues to sit open and unsolved, awaiting the crucial
piece of information or technological breakthrough that might finally reveal the identity of the killer.
This is Case File. Thanks for listening. See you next episode.

On January 11, 1965, 15-year-old Christine Sharrock and Marianne Schmidt spent the day at Cronulla Beach with Marianne's four younger siblings. After lunch, the two teenagers went for a walk into the nearby sandhills at Wanda Beach, but never returned.

The following day, their bodies were found in the sand dunes. The murders shocked the nation, triggering one of the largest homicide investigations in Australian history. Despite an exhaustive inquiry, police were unable to identify the killer. Decades on, the mystery remains.

---

Casefile Archives is a series of special bonus releases revisiting the earliest years of the show. The re-run episodes have been completely edited, polished, re-recorded and freshly produced from start to finish to match our current production standards. They are not complete rewrites - our goal wasn’t to alter the cases or reshape the writing, but to preserve the original storytelling while giving the production the refinement it didn’t have when we started the show back in 2016.

Where appropriate, updates have been added, but the core structure and storytelling remain faithful to the originals. Because of this, these re-releases may sound a little different to our recent episodes, but they allow us to bring some of the earliest episodes up to the technical quality listeners expect today.

CREDITS Narration – Anonymous Host Research & writing – Anonymous Host Production & music – Mike Migas Audio editing – Anthony Telfer

SOCIAL LINKS

Website https://www.casefilepodcast.com Facebook https://www.facebook.com/casefile Twitter https://twitter.com/case_file Instagram https://www.instagram.com/casefilepodcast Patreon https://www.patreon.com/casefile Casefile Presents https://casefilepresents.com

RESOURCES

For all credits and sources, please visit https://casefilepodcast.com/casefile-archives-1-the-wanda-beach-murders

Brief Summary

The episode revisits the Wonder Beach murders, detailing the investigation and suspects in the case of Maryanne Schmidt and Christine Sherik.

Key points

10 Years of Case File. Celebrating a decade of storytelling with a loyal audience and new content.
Introducing Case File Archives. A special series revisiting early episodes as a 10-year anniversary treat.
The W Beach Murders. A chilling case of two missing girls that led to a horrific discovery.
Discovery of the Bodies. The shocking moment when the bodies of the two girls were found in the sand.
The Mysterious Food in Christine's Stomach. Investigators discover undigested food in Christine's stomach, raising questions about her last meal.
The Hunt for the Surfy Teenager. Police begin searching for a teenager seen with the girls before their disappearance.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

A vicious and ruthless killer has never been brought to justice.

Describing the unresolved case of the W Beach murders.

5:07WatchJan 9, 2026

Tension

70/ 100High tension

More from Casefile

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.