Matthew Hoffman: The Leaf Killer | Making A Serial Killer | Forensic Files

[suspenseful music] When we saw the enormity of the crime scene, [camera clicks]
It was very clear that something really terrible had happened. [camera clicks] This is the first time they have ever seen Matthew Hoffman.
But this is not the first time Matthew Hoffman has seen them. With the amount of blood that we saw,
it's clear that they could die very shortly if we didn't recover them. When you look at it, I think it certainly is a domino effect.
Where do I stop? [suspenseful music] The level of violence that he displayed is far beyond anyone
that I've ever really seen. [theme music] Matthew Hoffman, his mom described him
from an early age as somebody who was interested in trees, loved to climb. He would take his friends in trees.
Friends of his said he was incredibly bright, but had no common sense. Kind of a quiet kid, somebody who liked to jump on things
and jump off of things, kind of a risk-taker. And also, a kid sometimes who seemed to struggle,
sometimes, socially. Not a behavioral problem so they just kind of, I think, shrugged it off for the most part as,
well, that's just Matthew. NARRATOR: In 2001, 20-year-old Matthew Hoffman has his
first encounter with the law. After he graduated, he seemed to get lost, like he didn't really know exactly what he wanted to do.
He's living with his mom, and so he eventually decides to get a job in Colorado.
So he moves to Colorado Springs and he's working as a plumber's assistant. People tend to like him.
He makes a good impression at the beginning. He realizes that one of his jobs-- the owner of the condominium, is going to be out of town.
And so he decides to essentially visit and set up camp there. Cooking meals there, watching cable TV.
He's using the Jacuzzi or the hot tub. He ends up stealing some things out of the home.
And then in his head, he is concerned about all these fingerprints that he might have left behind.
And so what does he decide? He decides to burn up the condominium. Arson was one in which we often find juveniles
are very much involved in. But to have an arson to cover up another crime is another level.
We start to see the development here of an individual that has tendencies that are not socially bonded,
that can lead to more serious crime in the future. It suggests a couple of things.
It suggests certainly poor judgment, poor decision-making, and just a complete disregard for the safety of other people
who are in that condominium complex. So at this point, he decides he needs to go back to Ohio
and live with his mom. Meanwhile, in Colorado, there are these investigations. They ask him, did you do it?
And he goes, yep, I did do it. And so they said, you've got to come back and face these charges.
So he gets in the car and he drives back to Colorado. And he ends up serving six years.
My name is Bob Moledor, and I'm a retired Columbus police officer. I was assigned to the Columbus resident agency FBI
as a member of their Violent Crime Task force. After he committed the burglaries in Colorado
and set those buildings on fire to cover his crime, being caught and sent to prison was very hard on Matthew.
He had a very difficult time in prison, and it was a very bad experience. Eventually, he gets out at six years.
He gets a job as a tree trimmer. He ends up saving up some money and he buys a little house.
His neighbors initially describe him as a good guy. And then starting, you know, at the end of the summer of 2010,
people just notice this abrupt change in him. He had developed this fascination with squirrels in his yard, and neighbors had noticed this.
And all of a sudden, he starts trapping and killing and eating them. Whenever somebody's behavior starts changing, particularly
of course when it's changing for the worse, that's a red flag. Something is going on.
As we look at the research related to serial killing and violent crime, we often do see a pathway to that.
The mistreatment of animals, the abuse being shown early age. And here, we have another example of this.
The ability to control one's environment is seen as something that we all want to do.
But the question becomes, how we do it? [suspenseful music] He becomes violent with his girlfriend, who then leaves.
His boss finds out that he's misrepresented his qualifications and that he had failed to tell them
that he had a criminal record. He's starting to watch the neighbors. They talk about him just literally sitting in a tree
and staring at them for hours. I believe that Matthew Hoffman made a good faith effort when he got out of prison to lead
a normal, law-abiding life. And I think it wore on him. And I think over time, he got tired of pretending
to be something he was not. Because in reality, he was a deeply disturbed and troubled person.
My name is Harry Trombitas. I'm a retired FBI agent. During the Matthew Hoffman case, I was involved in investigations
of violent crime. [music playing] NARRATOR: Matthew Hoffman spends the night camped out
in the woods overlooking the home of the Hermann family, around 25 minutes from his house.
Mom Tina works at a local fast food restaurant, while her children, Sarah, 13, and Kody, 11, are popular pupils
at the local high school. Hoffman appears to be staking out the area for a burglary.
Tuesday night, he had seen the house. He drove his vehicle parked not too far from the area there.
And he actually spent the night in the woods right across the street from the house.
We have Hoffman literally camping out across the way from this house in suburban Mount Vernon, Ohio.
But there becomes this question of staying overnight is a very long time to look at your potential victim's house.
A typical burglar has the ability to see the issues, see the lack of security, and say that is a good target.
[music playing] So he waited for a while. He walked across the street from the woods.
And he was able to crawl underneath the garage door. He went into the garage. He kicked the door into the house,
actually into the kitchen. He said there was a sense of excitement of being in somebody else's house when they weren't there.
He hears the pickup truck pull back into the driveway and he hears Tina Hermann come back, parked
the vehicle in the driveway, and come in through the front door. [suspenseful music]
A burglar is one that wants to get in and out without any contact with an individual.
A burglar usually is not prepared to physically have an altercation with an individual.
Instead, we find that he attacks Tina. [suspenseful music] He immediately confronted her with the knife,
made her lie down on the bed. All of a sudden, another woman, Stephanie Sprang, shows up.
And she starts yelling at him and he's panicked. He doesn't know what to do, but he brought a knife in with him
and he panics and stabs Tina Hermann a couple of times in the back, gets up and runs
after Stephanie. And Stephanie, instead of leaving the house, she goes back into another bedroom.
He's able to catch her, stabs her a couple of times in the chest. Then he goes back to where Tina is and stabs
her a couple of more times. And he said, by this time, it's clear both women are dead.
Matthew Hoffman's motive depends on what you believe. He says that he just wanted to break
in to burglarize the house. However, there are some things that don't add up for me.
Number one, he brought a huge knife with him. Number two is he apparently attacks Tina the minute
she walks in the door. Number three, he takes nothing from the house. There's no evidence that he's burglarizing anything.
Not only did Matthew Hoffman brutally kill Tina and Stephanie, he continued to stab
them long after they were dead. There was no reason to keep stabbing them, and yet he did.
When you look at it, I think it certainly is a domino effect. I'm already in a terrible situation.
Then it moved to that of a murder, then another murder. Where do I stop? After Matthew Hoffman kills Tina and then kills Stephanie,
the dog is barking and he's worried that's going to draw attention. So he kills the dog as well.
He then proceeds to take each one, one at a time, into the bathtub, where he then basically
dismembers all of them. And puts them in plastic bags. So killing has occurred. Mother, the mother's friend, even the dog have been killed.
Now, the children come home. [music playing] NARRATOR: Matthew Hoffman has murdered
Tina Hermann and her friend Stephanie Sprang, So he carried them both into the bathroom
and started sawing their body parts. And while he's in there and finishing up with the two women,
the family dog was barking at him and that. So he killed the family dog as well.
And all of a sudden, he hears the children come in the door. They open the door and they see drops of blood on the floor.
And so immediately, Sarah and Kody call out for their mom and instantly, Matthew Hoffman comes running
out full force toward them. [suspenseful music] Sarah manages to run by him. Kody tries to run out the door.
He grabs Kody and stabs in the back of the head. And kills him pretty much instantly.
Meanwhile, Sarah is in her room, desperately fumbling for her phone, trying to call 911.
Unfortunately, before she can do that, Matthew burst into the room and does not kill her.
Stops, and then ties her up. I know it's horrendous. Here, we have a horrific situation
where the brother is killed, but the daughter is kept alive. I think we see control factor here.
13-year-old child exists in the picture. She is saved, I think, to be his controlling element.
Perhaps he's even thinking she can humanize me for the demon type activities that I have just done.
Serial killers, we often find, are more interested in those people in which they can control.
And for a male, it is often that of a female. Multiply that even to a smaller female,
a younger female, and the control element goes up. NARRATOR: Tina works at a local fast food restaurant,
and on the evening of her murder, Tina's boss is the first to worry that something isn't right.
This is Wednesday, November 10th of 2010. The first information I received was that Tina Hermann failed
to show up for her 4:00 PM start time at the local Dairy Queen. The manager was so concerned about Tina
not showing up because she had never missed work before. She had never been late.
So about 7 o'clock that night, a Sheriff's deputy went to the home, saw a blue pickup truck in the driveway,
which was registered to Tina. But when the deputy knocked on the door, nobody came to the door.
So he left. And then he went back later that night around 11 o'clock. Knocked on the door again, no activity, nobody
came to the door. There didn't seem to be any problem. [music playing] NARRATOR: The day after the attack, Stephanie Sprang's
boyfriend reports her missing and the police discover that Sarah and Kody haven't gone into school.
Tina's boss is even more worried. Tina still hadn't shown up for her shift. The manager got so concerned, she went ahead
and drove to Tina's house. There were no cars in the driveway and she noticed a window was partly ajar.
So she was able to raise it, and actually get into the kitchen. NARRATOR: On seeing the crime scene,
the local Sheriff's office asked the FBI for assistance. Harry just contacted us and said,
looks like we have a homicide up here and we're going to need some help. When we saw the enormity of the crime scene,
it was very clear that something really terrible had happened. NARRATOR: Investigators arrive just
hours after Hoffman has left. At this stage, investigators are unaware of his involvement.
It's not clear if any of the victims are still alive or where they've gone. Do we have any inclination, was this self-inflicted?
Do we have any information that tells us, was there another person? Are there any cameras, any neighbors, or any individuals
that can give us time frame so that we can have a picture of when did this happen?
There's not a lot of wealth in the house. There's no indication that there is any kind of narcotics activity taking place at the house.
So we had four people that seemingly disappeared off the face of the earth. We felt as though there had to be at least one other person
involved, possibly two. We had a real life whodunit on our hands. If they weren't already dead, with the amount of blood
and everything that we saw, it's clear that they could die very shortly if we didn't recover them.
[suspenseful music] NARRATOR: Police immediately conduct interviews with known contacts of Tina and Stephanie.
Tina's boyfriend was a suspect at the time, but he was very cooperative. He provided an alibi to us.
It appeared as though he had nothing to do with this. We knew Tina and actually Stephanie had been
out and about on Wednesday. Could have met anybody, could somebody have followed him home,
it was pretty much an unknown because we had received no information, no suspicious people or vehicle reports
in the area. So it was truly a mystery at that point. [suspenseful music] NARRATOR: Police are still looking
for the perpetrator and the victims of what appears to be a murder. The crime scene was pretty much based out of the bathroom,
yet there was blood also down the hallway. There were two bedrooms where they found blood.
And once they finished inside the house, they went into the garage and started processing
the items inside the garage. And they found a bag from Walmart. They looked inside and they found a receipt where somebody
had gone on Thursday and made a purchase of some heavy duty garbage bags and a couple of tarps.
That is where the first big break in the case came, was the discovery of a receipt at the crime scene.
That receipt really broke the case open. Now, people should know there's a lot of information
on your receipt from Walmart. It tells what items you purchased. It tells the location in which you purchased them.
And the time and date in which you purchased them. That's a lot of information that can get an investigation going.
So good policing says, let's go to this Walmart. Let's look at the cameras. Let's try to put evidence together to see
who does this bag belong to. NARRATOR: Police are yet to identify Hoffman as a suspect.
Since breaking into the Hermann's house and killing Tina, Stephanie, Kody, and the family dog,
he's moved the bodies, but he's still keeping Sarah alive. She's now his prisoner.
[suspenseful music] And he takes Sarah to his home. Finds her, keeps her bound up, puts her in the crawlspace,
told her that he had accomplices, that if she made any noises or anything, they would be there to take care of her and perhaps kill her
if she didn't continue to cooperate. Won't let her take a shower. Won't let her go to the bathroom.
He sexually assaults her on multiple occasions. [music playing] I think Matthew's motivation is sex and control.
Not only does he want to have sex, I think, with Sarah, but he wants to have complete control over her.
I think that Kody and Tina and Stephanie were collateral damage in this situation,
that he just wanted to get them out of the way and he was willing to kill anybody that he
needed to, to get Sarah. I think this desire to essentially capture somebody and have them under your total control
is so telling in terms of that person's psychology. I think there was some fantasy going on for him.
This is going to be like a girlfriend or this is going to be somebody who we're going to watch a movies together,
which of course, would never, ever, ever happen. [suspenseful music] NARRATOR: Police don't know if Sarah or her family are alive
or where they are. So far, their only lead is a Walmart receipt found in the Hermann's garage.
They don't know they're in a race against time to save the only survivor. The family went missing technically on Wednesday.
We really didn't know about it until Thursday. It wasn't until Friday that they found the receipt.
So the investigators went to the Walmart and they were able to pull up video of the individual that was in there shortly after midnight.
And they saw this person walking in the Walmart store, going directly to the tarps and the garbage bags,
and buying those. Going up to the cash register, unfortunately paid with cash so we weren't able to get a name.
But we could see him walking to his vehicle, turned out to be a Toyota Yaris. So let's pull up all the known Toyota Yarises in this area.
They were able to click on the information about one of the Yarises and it belonged to an individual
by the name of Matthew Hoffman. So they pulled up his driver's license photo, and he happened to have the same shirt on in his driver's license
photo that we saw in the video of the individual that was walking around in the Walmart.
And that's when Matthew Hoffman was identified as a suspect. Once that occurred, they did some quick background
information checks. He is a convicted felon for some crimes that he had done in Colorado, spent time out there in prison.
You then now start looking at that person as your person of interest. They find Hoffman has been fired from his job,
has a case of domestic violence against him. We're starting to see the puzzle gather
pieces that may fit together. [suspenseful music] Saturday night, heading into Sunday morning,
we were able to get the search warrant. And based on what we found with the tarps and the garbage bags,
we felt we had enough information there to get an arrest warrant for him. NARRATOR: Police have two addresses for Hoffman.
One of them is his house and the other his parents', both a short drive from the Hermann's.
Police plan to monitor both properties simultaneously. Harry Trombitas heads to Matthew Hoffman's parents' house.
Bob Moledor heads to Matthew Hoffman's house. So we're going to the residents that belong to Matthew Hoffman.
Because of the condition of the crime scene, I don't believe that anybody there really expected that we were going to find anyone alive.
So right now in the investigation, you know that Hoffman is a person of interest,
but you don't know where the people who lived at the crime scene where they are.
So this is a very tense time. And the question still remains, where are these people?
And how are we going to find them? [suspenseful music] NARRATOR: Police have evidence linking Matthew Hoffman
to the suspected murderers of Tina Hermann, her children, Sarah and Kody, and her friend
Stephanie Sprang. They have no idea that Sarah is still alive and are preparing to search his parents'
home and his own residence. Has he fled the state? If not, where is he? We had to assume that the possibility was there
that Hoffman would be either house. We pulled up in front of Matthew's mom's house.
We're wearing our bulletproof vests. We've got our handguns out. I said, I'm with the FBI.
We're looking for Matthew. Is he here? The stepdad said no. We were disappointed that we didn't find him there,
but we realized that more than likely, Matthew would be at the house in Mount Vernon.
[suspenseful music] When the officers went to the door, they knocked and announced.
And he actually came to the door. So he was taken into custody right away. As far as Matthew's demeanor, he was quiet.
He almost seemed relieved that we were there. But as you go into the house, the first thing that you see off
to your right-hand side is a living room without any furniture inside, but there's a enormous pile
of leaves covering the floor. It covers an entire room. It was really shocking. We looked at that and wondered right away,
are we going to find four bodies covered up in this pile of leaves? NARRATOR: With Hoffman now in custody,
the SWAT team searched for survivors, fearing the worst. Anytime a tactical team enters a house like that, the first thing
that they do is conduct a room-to-room search. There were carcasses of animals in his refrigerator.
The house itself was in a state of disarray. And it was during that search that Sarah was located
in the basement of the home. Everyone who was involved in that was just shocked that we had this young girl and she was OK.
She was bound and sleeping in a pile of leaves with some blankets. She was pretty confused.
Obviously, she was scared, but relieved. [suspenseful music] The main point now is to move that 13-year-old Sarah to safety
and then to get her to give us as much information about what occurred. We quickly interviewed Sarah to see if she
knew where her family was. He had indicated to her that he was holding her hostage
until the family provided whatever money and that that they were negotiating. He even showed her what the word "ransom"
means in the dictionary. NARRATOR: With Sarah now safe, investigators are desperate to learn the fate of Hoffman's other victims.
You now have Hoffman in custody. And usually, what we find is that an individual
that's in this situation is usually fearful, uncertain, and scared. And so with all of that coming at them,
they want to defend themselves. And they usually say at least something. But he does not.
He does not for four hours. Wow. He just sat there like he was in a trance. After a couple of hours of him just sitting there,
he made a motion like, Then he does this like he's breaking something. And he kind of nods yes.
And that was all they could get out of it. I think the longer this capture or kidnapping went on,
I think the harder it would have been for Matthew to let Sarah go for a couple of reasons.
One is she's been missing for so long and the criminal charges are going to be just
racking up longer and longer. And I think he would have considered her kind of his.
He's also killed most of her family. So if he lets her go, she is now going to find out that he has murdered her mother,
her brother, and her dog. NARRATOR: With Hoffman offering no information, police use other tactics to help them understand what's happened
to Tina, Kody, and Stephanie. I was given the responsibility of escorting his ex-girlfriend.
He would take this young lady on dates and he would find a huge tree, put up his equipment,
hoist them up 30 or 40 feet in the air, and they would hang out for a whole Saturday in the hammocks
in the canopy of these trees. NARRATOR: Bob hopes that he'll find some clues by driving to the places
that Hoffman visited with his ex. She said that he was actually polite most of the time,
but towards the end of their relationship, he was prone to fits of anger and they would come on quickly.
When she finally put an end to the relationship, it was because he had held her down and choked her to the point
that she thought she was going to lose consciousness. And that really scared her.
It seems like Matthew liked the thrill of being in someone's house that didn't belong
to him when they weren't there. That's what I was hearing from the words of his former girlfriend.
And in her case, that led to the demise of their relationship as she came to know him better.
So she and I drove all over Knox County, put hundreds of miles on my truck those couple of days,
but to no avail. We just assumed that they were dead and that they were hidden somewhere.
And it was going to be up to Matthew Hoffman to tell us where they were. You can start to then think, was
there a movement of body parts? Are the pieces all in one place? And this is where they make the horrific finding.
[suspenseful music] NARRATOR: Matthew Hoffman is in custody for the kidnapping of Sarah Maynard and the suspected murder
of her mom, Tina, her brother Kody, and her mom's friend, Stephanie. After two days of interrogation, the police
have no information about whether or not he's killed Sarah's family or what he might
have done with their bodies. He didn't talk a lot. He seemed easily frustrated. He was just sort of a haunted personality.
It was extremely frustrating. We just weren't able to get him to admit anything or tell us any of the information at that point.
He was eligible for the death penalty, but we wanted to find out where the family was.
So basically, the prosecutor said, we think that if we drop the death penalty charges
against Matthew Hoffman, in exchange, he'll tell us where your family members are.
And all of the family members were in agreement that they wanted to know where their loved ones were
so they can bring them home. What's extremely important is trying to bring closure not just
to that of the case, but what is very important, to the families. Not knowing is often the question that
eats at them every single day. NARRATOR: The deal works. With the prospect of the death penalty removed,
Hoffman reveals the truth in a written statement. In his statement, Matthew Hoffman
indicated that while he completed, you know, processing the bodies, he realized that those bags weren't going to be strong enough for him.
So he loaded Sarah and the body parts into Stephanie's vehicle, and he parks the vehicle,
goes back and gets his vehicle. And he takes Sarah to his home, finds her, keeps her bound up,
and goes to the Walmart where he purchases the garbage bags and the tarp, transfers the body parts that are in the smaller
bags into the larger bags, goes to Kokosing wildlife area, which is about 10 miles from Tina's house.
And had remembered a tree that he had a particular liking to. This is a 60-foot tree.
And about halfway up is a hollowed out area. And he hauls the body parts up, drops them down the center,
and then he goes back home. He tells us these different things. You know, it's just very difficult for us
to believe what he went through to do this. So we were very skeptical. During his interviews, they talked
to him about why he chose to dispose of the bodies in that manner. And he said that at one point, he
had thought about putting the bodies into Stephanie Sprang's Jeep vehicle and driving it into a pond
and letting it sink. The reason he didn't do that was because he was concerned that because of the water temperature and the time of year
that he would not be able to safely escape from the vehicle and swim to shore. So that tells me that this is a guy who's--
he's worrying about himself. So the attorney leads us out to Kokosing wildlife preserve.
And all of a sudden, after, you know, a quarter of a mile or so, he stops, he gets out of his vehicle,
he's looking at the map and he comes back to the Sheriff's car and he goes, I think that's the tree right there.
You got to be kidding me. This tree is 60 feet tall. There is a hollowed out portion in the tree,
but it's 30 feet off the ground. And, you know, we're just real skeptical. The crime scene guys, they got a saw
and they cut out, about 6 feet off the ground, a little hole where they could stick a pole and a mirror
attached to the end. And as they're looking, they go, I think we see garbage bags down there.
And sure enough, just like Matthew Hoffman had said that he had dropped seven garbage
bags down the center of the tree and inside the garbage bags were the body parts.
Those bodies may not have been discovered for decades in that tree the way they were.
It's very possible it could have been 50 or 60 years go by until that tree rotted and fell,
that those bodies would have been discovered. I think that for Matthew Hoffman, trees meant so many things.
And I think one of the things they did mean to him is like it's a sacred space for him.
And it's a place that's his. And so I think by putting these bodies down in this tree, number one, it'd be
almost impossible to find them. It's that practical part of it. But I think even more importantly
for him psychologically is it was kind of like, if not like an offering, a sacred place that was his.
So it was a sense of ownership as well that he's putting them in this tree. [music playing]
He faces aggravated murder, abuse of a corpse, burglary, kidnapping, and rape. When you're going into trial with such an emotional case that
has the loss of life and still has a 13-year-old that went through this ordeal, you've got
a lot there to deal with. The family was all there. I remember being in the courtroom.
There was no trial. It was just a plea. He pled guilty. And, you know, it's just awful situation for the families,
certainly for Sarah. He is sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
We see some horrific things throughout our careers, and to recover, you know, a family is just a horrific thing.
Nobody should ever have to go through that. But, you know, that's what we do in law enforcement.
We see the worst of the worst. But, you know, it was closure for them. Matthew Hoffman will never, ever get out of prison again.
[music playing] As far as Hoffman's mindset, it's so difficult to tell exactly where
he was at the particular time. I've been involved in a number of cases where this kind of thing will repulse somebody.
And I've also worked cases where when somebody actually does this, and they feel the power of control.
It can feel a fire inside them that, you know, I like this feeling. I think that he was escalating.
Once he had killed, I think he would have killed again. [music playing] My daughter, who is now an adult,
actually teaches at the middle school where Sarah and her brother went to school at,
and she lives in the Mount Vernon community. Kody would have graduated in 2019. And for the graduation ceremony, the school
placed a chair with Kody's cap and gown and his diploma on that chair, along with a white rose.
When my daughter sent me that photograph, it hit me like a load of bricks. This particular case has always stuck with me.
I have kind of followed after Sarah to just kind see how she's getting along in life.
It's unimaginable to me how you could experience something this horrific and still go on.
I'm just honored to have been able to afford her the opportunity to have a life and just hope and pray
that she finds solace and can go on with her life and not allow this experience to define who she is.
[music playing] [theme music]

Mount Vernon, Ohio is rocked by a brutal family massacre that sends the town into a frenzy to find the sole surviving victim – a teen girl that had been abducted by the perpetrator, Matthew Hoffman.

The so-called “Leaf Killer” was obsessed with trees but his calm demeanor masked his internal fantasies for violence.

=============== Like, comment and subscribe if you’re ready for more true crime. Your favorite shows like World’s Most Evil Killers, Meet Marry Murder, Forensic Files, Unsolved Mysteries, Murdered At First Sight and Bloodline Detectives are all available to stream 24/7 for free via the FilmRise Streaming Network. You can access The FilmRise Streaming Network through most free App Platforms and Smart TV portals such as Amazon Fire TV, The Roku Channel, Android, iOS and many more.

Brief Summary

Matthew Hoffman murders a family and kidnaps a girl, revealing a disturbing psychological profile and leading to his arrest and life sentence.

Key points

Matthew Hoffman's First Encounter with the Law. In 2001, Matthew Hoffman has his first run-in with the law, marking the start of his troubled path.
The Brutal Murders of Tina and Stephanie. Matthew Hoffman brutally kills Tina Hermann and her friend Stephanie Sprang in a shocking act of violence.
The Discovery of a Key Receipt. A Walmart receipt found at the crime scene becomes a crucial piece of evidence linking Hoffman to the murders.
Matthew Hoffman's Arrest. Matthew Hoffman is taken into custody, revealing a shocking scene inside his home.
The Discovery of Sarah. A young girl, Sarah, is found alive in a shocking situation.
Hoffman's Confession. Matthew Hoffman reveals the location of the bodies after a plea deal.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

Where do I stop?

Matthew Hoffman's internal conflict after committing murders.

0:42WatchNov 15, 2024

Tension

85/ 100High tension

More from True Crime Files

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.