Episode 328
- Nov 17, 2025
- 1:08:47
- Full Episode
Synchronizing the audio with the ad breaks and transcriptThis takes a brief moment, please wait.
In a quiet Ohio town shaped by coal and tradition, Brad McGarry is found dead in his basement. At first, it looks like a break-in. But as detectives dig deeper, they uncover a complex friendship, a hidden relationship, and a web of lies that unravels in the interrogation room. This is a story of secrets, pressure, and the cost of keeping them buried.<br /><br />Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com
Brief Summary
David Kinney is convicted of murdering his best friend Brad McGarry in a case of betrayal and hidden relationships.
Key points
- The Discovery of Brad McGarry. On May 7, 2017, Brad McGarry was found dead in his basement, raising shocking questions.
- Courtney's Alarming Lead. A cab driver reveals a woman named Courtney planned to rob a man she met online.
- The Investigation Deepens. Detectives uncover parts of Brad's life that hint at hidden dangers.
- The Pressure Mounts. As the interrogation intensifies, David's story begins to unravel.
- The Truth About Brad. David reveals the complexity of his relationship with Brad amidst the investigation.
- David's Confession. David admits he loved Brad but insists he didn't kill him.
Episode highlights
- The Discovery of Brad McGarryOn May 7, 2017, Brad McGarry was found dead in his basement, raising shocking questions.“How did this happen?”9:40Nov 17, 2025
- Courtney's Alarming LeadA cab driver reveals a woman named Courtney planned to rob a man she met online.“She saved his number under the name Baby Raper.”16:19Nov 17, 2025
- The Investigation DeepensDetectives uncover parts of Brad's life that hint at hidden dangers.“Was Brad McGarry living a life no one knew about?”16:55Nov 17, 2025
- The Pressure MountsAs the interrogation intensifies, David's story begins to unravel.“This is your chance to get in front of this.”37:21Nov 17, 2025
- The Truth About BradDavid reveals the complexity of his relationship with Brad amidst the investigation.“I love them, not like I do my wife.”46:45Nov 17, 2025
- David's ConfessionDavid admits he loved Brad but insists he didn't kill him.“I did not shoot him.”46:54Nov 17, 2025
- The Detective's TheoryDetective Villar suggests David's guilt may have led to a false narrative.“You can't live with yourself about what happened.”48:35Nov 17, 2025
- The Final LiesDavid's lies begin to catch up with him as the detective closes in.“Detective Alar was closing in.”51:25Nov 17, 2025
Tension
85/ 100High tension
