Episode 307
- Jul 17, 2025
- 1:15:37
- Full Episode
Synchronizing the audio with the ad breaks and transcriptThis takes a brief moment, please wait.
When Katelyn Markham vanished without a trace, investigators were left chasing shadows. A registered sex offender. A troubled coworker. A longtime fiancé with too many explanations. But as leads faded and the case grew cold, the real truth remained buried - until, 12 years later, a forgotten clue cracked the mystery wide open. Who was responsible for Katelyn’s fate? And why did it take more than a decade to bring them to justice?<br /><br />Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com
Brief Summary
Caitlin Markham's remains were found, leading to her fiancé John Carter's arrest for involuntary manslaughter after years of investigation.
Key points
- The Discovery. Andy and his wife stumble upon human remains while hunting for scrap metal.
- Caitlin's Vanishing. Caitlin Markham disappears just before her 22nd birthday, leaving her life behind.
- The CVSA Test Results. John's CVSA test shows signs of deception, raising suspicions about his involvement.
- The Discovery of Caitlin's Remains. Caitlin's remains are found, leading to a renewed investigation into her disappearance.
- A New Suspect Emerges. Detectives focus on John Carter after Caitlin's remains are found near his father's property.
- Jonathan's Alibi Falls Apart. Jonathan Palmerton's alibi crumbles when his friend denies being with him that night.
Episode highlights
- The DiscoveryAndy and his wife stumble upon human remains while hunting for scrap metal.“But this time, they would find so much more.”2:19Jul 17, 2025
- Caitlin's VanishingCaitlin Markham disappears just before her 22nd birthday, leaving her life behind.“It was like she had just disappeared without a trace.”15:11Jul 17, 2025
- The CVSA Test ResultsJohn's CVSA test shows signs of deception, raising suspicions about his involvement.“John was at a loss.”28:23Jul 17, 2025
- The Discovery of Caitlin's RemainsCaitlin's remains are found, leading to a renewed investigation into her disappearance.“The investigation would go on for one year and eight months.”32:46Jul 17, 2025
- A New Suspect EmergesDetectives focus on John Carter after Caitlin's remains are found near his father's property.“Suddenly, the ISP's only focus became John Carter.”33:54Jul 17, 2025
- Jonathan's Alibi Falls ApartJonathan Palmerton's alibi crumbles when his friend denies being with him that night.“Just like that, Palmerton's alibi fell apart.”45:34Jul 17, 2025
- The Poem's Dark RevelationA disturbing poem found at John's house hints at a troubled psyche.“The poem reads like someone arguing with themselves.”49:09Jul 17, 2025
- John Carter's ArrestJohn Carter was arrested and charged with murder after Caitlin's disappearance.“John Carter was arrested and charged with unclassified murder.”57:32Jul 17, 2025
Tension
85/ 100High tension
