Deadly Valentine
- Sep 18, 2021
- 1:23:43
- Full Episode
Synchronizing the audio with the ad breaks and transcriptThis takes a brief moment, please wait.
<p>A missionary's wife and mother of three is found dead in her house on Valentine's Day. As authorities investigate, questions surrounding the murder hit close to home. Andrea Canning has chosen this episode as one of her most memorable classic episodes.</p><p> </p><br/> <p>Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See <a href="https://pcm.adswizz.com">pcm.adswizz.com</a> for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.</p>
Brief Summary
Nathan Luthold was convicted of murdering his wife Denise on Valentine's Day 2013, driven by an affair with a young exchange student.
Key points
- The Shocking Discovery. Nathan Luthold discovers a break-in at his home, leading to a horrifying revelation.
- Community in Shock. The quiet town of Peoria grapples with the fallout of a brutal murder.
- Nathan's Emotional Struggle. Nathan grapples with explaining his wife's death to their children, showcasing his deep sorrow.
- Suspicious Circumstances. Detectives uncover inconsistencies in Nathan's story, raising doubts about his innocence.
- Uncovering Dark Secrets. Nathan's internet search history reveals disturbing thoughts, suggesting premeditated intentions.
- Nathan's Arrest. Three weeks after Denise's murder, Nathan Luthold is arrested, shocking those who knew him.
Episode highlights
- The Shocking DiscoveryNathan Luthold discovers a break-in at his home, leading to a horrifying revelation.“My world had just been shattered.”1:02Sep 18, 2021
- Community in ShockThe quiet town of Peoria grapples with the fallout of a brutal murder.“This stuff doesn't happen in this neighborhood.”17:46Sep 18, 2021
- Nathan's Emotional StruggleNathan grapples with explaining his wife's death to their children, showcasing his deep sorrow.“Mom went home to be with God.”25:01Sep 18, 2021
- Suspicious CircumstancesDetectives uncover inconsistencies in Nathan's story, raising doubts about his innocence.“Things just weren't adding up.”34:28Sep 18, 2021
- Uncovering Dark SecretsNathan's internet search history reveals disturbing thoughts, suggesting premeditated intentions.“He owned and she was shot with.”44:20Sep 18, 2021
- Nathan's ArrestThree weeks after Denise's murder, Nathan Luthold is arrested, shocking those who knew him.“He seemed scared. He seemed surprised.”46:33Sep 18, 2021
- The Valentine's Day MurderProsecutors argue Nathan killed his wife on Valentine's Day to be with another woman.“This was his Valentine's Day present to Ina, and that is despicable.”47:25Sep 18, 2021
- Ina's TestimonyIna Dabilita's testimony raises questions about her relationship with Nathan and the murder.“I think it was significant for the jury to see Ina.”1:00:47Sep 18, 2021
Tension
85/ 100High tension
