Andrew Mook testifies in brother's trial | Forensic Files

when Tyler picks Robin up to throw her in the water do you hear Robin say no I can recall yes sir do you hear her say
stop does she call for help for you at that point in time I can't remember the conversation
part okay she goes in the water and Tyler goes in after her now you said Tyler on the shoulders he pushed her
under yes sir and you said this was two or three times that's correct he pushes her under
the first time she's able to come back up yes when she comes back up do you hear her saying anything at that point
in time yes is that when she called for you yes sir when she yelled you can understand what she was saying yes do
you see Tyler punching her in the water no sir do you see him kicking her in the
water no sir you see him flipping her around in the water I don't recall no sir you see your feet sticking up out of
the water I can't recall okay now when you jump in the water you jump in the water because Nicole tells
you to jump in the water yes sir now when you jump in the water you throw the noodle in you grab the noodle the first
first thing you do is give the noodle to Robin yes sir okay I assume Robin is above water at this point in time that
is correct so at this point in time that's when you get Tyler in a choke hold yes sir okay and when you got Tyler
in a choke hold he wasn't pushing her underwater that's correct and what do you do with Tyler you take him back I
let him go and he turns around and swims back to the boat he's not fighting to get away from
you no sir he's not fighting to get back to Robin no sir sir when you let him go
does he go back toward Robin no sir

In court, Andrew describes Tyler Mook throwing Robin Doneth from a speedboat in Florida.

"48 Hours" investigates the most intriguing crime and justice cases that touch on all areas of the human experience including greed and passion. For 27 seasons, "48 Hours" has developed a rich history of original reporting and impact journalism that has helped exonerate wrongly convicted people, caused cold cases to be reopened and solved, and along the way changed lives. Check local listings for "48 Hours" broadcast times.

Brief Summary

Witness recounts a water incident involving Tyler and Robin's struggle.

Key points

Tyler's Actions. Tyler pushes Robin underwater multiple times, raising questions about his intentions.
Jumping In. The witness jumps in the water at Nicole's urging to save Robin.
Choke Hold. The witness puts Tyler in a choke hold to stop him from harming Robin.

Episode highlights

Episode quotes

Do you hear her say no?

Robin's plea as she is thrown in the water

0:15WatchOct 30, 2016

More from 48 Hours

Solve the Crime

Read a real case one clue at a time, then see how your call held up against the investigators.